Equipment integrity and maintenance

Approx. 70–105 minutes

Independent SHAREhub awareness. This course does not provide a NEBOSH qualification, accreditation or authority to operate, design, isolate, test or maintain plant. Use competent site arrangements for real work.

This reader supplies the complete teaching. Use the interactive LMS course for assessed activities, saved progress and completion.

LESSON 1

Start with the function that must survive

Explain integrity using a containment boundary and its credited safeguards.

Closed pipework and vessels in a UK chemical processing plant
Existing SHAREhub photographic illustration. The written fictional case supplies the condition and decision evidence.

Understand the decision

Mechanical integrity concerns whether equipment can continue performing its intended duty. Asset integrity also involves the people, information and decisions that keep that duty credible through the plant life. A current certificate for one vessel cannot establish the condition of connected pipework, its supports or the emergency isolation function.

Start with what can escape, the credible route of failure and who could be harmed. Then identify the relevant equipment and the evidence that supports its use in this service. This prevents a tidy asset register becoming a substitute for understanding the hazard.

What do asset integrity and mechanical integrity mean?

Asset integrity is the broader system for keeping assets safe; mechanical integrity is the physical equipment condition discipline within it.

In process safety, asset integrity is not just maintenance, certification or a tidy asset list. It is the discipline that keeps plant within safe design intent as it ages, operates, corrodes, vibrates, heats, cools, starts up, shuts down and changes service.

Mechanical integrity is more focused on physical equipment. It asks whether a vessel, pipe, tank, valve, relief device, exchanger, pump, support or rotating item is still fit for its intended service and whether inspection, testing, repair and replacement decisions are technically justified.

The two are inseparable. A pressure vessel may have an inspection certificate, but asset integrity can still be weak if corrosion data is not reviewed, relief valves are overdue, operating limits are ignored, repairs are informal or managers approve deferrals without understanding the major accident risk.

Integrity definitions and practical meaning - Integrity definitions and practical meaning
Term Plain-English meaning Practical evidence
Asset integrity Whole-life assurance that plant and safeguards remain fit for safe operation. Asset register, performance standards, inspection strategy and barrier health review.
Mechanical integrity Condition and fitness-for-service control of physical equipment. Inspection records, NDT, thickness data, repairs, replacements and WSEs.
Safety-critical equipment Equipment whose failure could cause or escalate a major accident, or whose function prevents or mitigates one. Major accident hazard register and barrier mapping.
Fitness for service Technical judgement that equipment can safely continue operating within defined limits. Competent engineering assessment and documented operating restrictions.
Operating envelope Safe limits for pressure, temperature, flow, level, chemistry, corrosion and other conditions. Alarm set points, operating procedures and excursion review.

Applied case

A vessel examination is current, but the connecting solvent return line has unexplained staining.

Mechanical integrity

The equipment must remain suitable for its actual duty and condition.

Asset integrity

People, information and accountable decisions keep equipment capability credible over its life.

Test your decision

What does the vessel record establish?

  1. Evidence within its examination scope; the return-line anomaly still needs assessment.
  2. The connected circuit is safe until the next vessel examination.
  3. The stain can be closed because it is outside the vessel shell.
Compare the explanation

Evidence within its examination scope; the return-line anomaly still needs assessment.

An examination has a defined scope. Trace the unassessed line to its containment function rather than extending the record beyond that scope.

Open this interactive lesson →

LESSON 2

Read the damage mechanism

Distinguish a visible warning from a measurement of remaining integrity.

Closed pipework and vessels in a UK chemical processing plant. Photorealistic illustration.
Photorealistic illustrative UK workplace scene. Review checks: Avoid / redesign: Remove obsolete plant, redundant pipework or unnecessary hazardous inventory. Control the task: Segregate hazardous plant, use remote operation and protect people from rupture zones. Verify before release: Decommissioning records and inventory reduction.

Understand the decision

Corrosion, erosion, fatigue and material incompatibility arise through different mechanisms. The relevant mechanism depends on service, environment, material and loading. Water-marked insulation can be a clue to hidden corrosion; a photograph cannot establish wall thickness or a safe remaining life.

Report the location, condition, operating context and change from previous observations without touching a suspected leak. A competent assessment decides what examination is needed and whether operation must be restricted. Painting over a stain or adding insulation can hide the signal while leaving the mechanism active.

Which degradation and damage mechanisms should be considered?

The relevant damage mechanisms depend on materials, service, temperature, pressure, chemistry, loading, age and operating history.

A good inspection scheme begins with a damage mechanism review. The review should ask what could happen to this equipment in this service, where it would appear, how quickly it could develop and which inspection technique can detect it before failure.

Common errors include inspecting convenient locations rather than likely damage locations, assuming historical low corrosion will continue after service changes, and using NDT methods that cannot detect the credible defect type.

Ageing plant is not automatically unsafe, but ageing assumptions must be tested. Missing material records, poor drawings, unknown repairs and obsolete equipment increase uncertainty and should trigger a more cautious approach.

Common integrity damage mechanisms - Common integrity damage mechanisms
Damage mechanism Where it may appear Assessment focus
General corrosion Pipework, vessels, tanks and supports. Corrosion rate, material, coating, inspection interval and remaining life.
Corrosion under insulation Insulated pipework, vessels and equipment exposed to moisture. CUI programme, inspection windows and wet insulation history.
Erosion High velocity flow, bends, reducers, slurry or particle-laden streams. Flow regime, wall thickness and vulnerable locations.
Fatigue Cyclic pressure, vibration, thermal cycling or rotating equipment. Stress cycles, supports, vibration and crack detection.
Stress corrosion cracking Specific material/environment combinations. Material selection, environment control and targeted NDT.
High-temperature hydrogen attack High-temperature hydrogen service. Metallurgy, service history and damage mechanism review.
Creep High-temperature service over time. Operating temperature, material life and inspection.
Mechanical damage Impact, denting, poor supports, vibration or external loads. Inspection after events and support condition.
Fouling or blockage Relief devices, small bore lines, strainers and heat exchangers. Proof testing, cleaning and process contamination.
Sources and references

Sources for this explanation: HSE Inspection and non-destructive testing; HSE Mechanical Integrity Intervention Tool.

Applied case

Rainwater has entered damaged cladding beside a warm process line.

Clue

Wet cladding can direct investigation without proving the concealed wall condition.

Measurement

A suitable examination needs defined coverage and competent interpretation.

Test your decision

Which conclusion fits the observation?

  1. Intact visible pipe at one edge proves the insulated length is sound.
  2. Possible hidden degradation needs a service-specific integrity review.
  3. If there is no active drip, the concealed pipe can be assumed sound.
Compare the explanation

Possible hidden degradation needs a service-specific integrity review.

A clue directs investigation. It does not measure concealed damage or authorise continued service.

Open this interactive lesson →

LESSON 3

Identify safety-critical equipment

Prioritise an item by the accident scenario and function it supports.

Closed pipework and vessels in a UK chemical processing plant. Photorealistic illustration.
Photorealistic illustrative UK workplace scene. Review checks: Change at source: Remove obsolete plant, redundant pipework or unnecessary hazardous inventory. Make it observable: Decommissioning records and inventory reduction. Keep useful evidence: Transfer checklist, alarm/ESD test status, defect or near-miss record and hand-back.

Understand the decision

Criticality follows consequences and barrier function, not purchase price or how often a component fails. A small shutdown actuator can matter more to a release scenario than a large non-critical utility pump. Record what event the item prevents, detects, controls or mitigates and what happens if it fails.

Use this connection when prioritising resources. The asset owner needs a clear function, responsible role, inspection or test requirements and an escalation route for impairment. An unlabelled component is not automatically unimportant; an unclear function is a reason to resolve the information gap.

Which assets and safeguards should be safety critical?

Items should be safety critical where their failure could cause, prevent, detect, control or mitigate a major accident.

Safety-critical equipment is not limited to pressure vessels and pipework. It may include level instruments, trips, alarms, interlocks, relief systems, emergency shutdown valves, gas detection, firewater, bunds, containment, ventilation, critical utilities and structural supports.

The classification should be tied to the major accident hazard register. If a barrier is credited with preventing or mitigating a major accident scenario, it should have defined performance standards and assurance evidence.

Safety-critical status should affect priority. Overdue inspection or maintenance on a safety-critical item should receive different escalation from a low-consequence comfort or convenience item.

Typical safety-critical assets and safeguards - Typical safety-critical assets and safeguards
Asset or safeguard Safety function Evidence to check
Pressure vessels and pipework Contain hazardous substances and stored energy. WSE, inspection history and safe operating limits.
Storage tanks and bunds Contain inventory and secondary containment. Tank inspection, overfill protection and bund inspection.
Relief valves and rupture discs Protect against overpressure. Relief basis, proof test and isolation control.
Alarms and trips Detect and prevent unsafe conditions. Functional test, response procedure and bypass log.
Interlocks and ESD systems Stop escalation automatically or remotely. Proof test, SIL/functional safety records and override control.
Gas/fire detection Detect loss of containment or fire. Calibration, coverage review and alarm response.
Critical utilities Support cooling, inerting, power, instrument air or firewater. Availability, maintenance and emergency backup.
Temporary repairs Maintain containment until permanent repair. Engineering approval, risk review and expiry date.
Sources and references

Sources for this explanation: HSE Mechanical Integrity Intervention Tool; HSE Functional safety.

Applied case

Two overdue jobs concern an office fan and the final element of a credited solvent isolation function.

Small item, large consequence

An inexpensive actuator can be essential to a major-accident protective function.

Criticality record

Connect the item to the scenario, required function, owner and assurance evidence.

Test your decision

What should drive their relative priority?

  1. The larger replacement cost.
  2. Which team entered the job first.
  3. The credible consequences and safety functions affected.
Compare the explanation

The credible consequences and safety functions affected.

A barrier-based priority connects the work to potential harm. Cost and queue age do not establish equivalent risk.

Open this interactive lesson →

LESSON 4

Match the strategy to the failure

Compare preventive, condition-based and corrective maintenance.

Maintenance lock-off equipment on a UK machine isolator
Existing SHAREhub photographic illustration. The written fictional case supplies the condition and decision evidence.

Understand the decision

Time-based preventive work can address a known age-related mechanism. Condition monitoring uses reliable observations to detect deterioration before an unacceptable state. Corrective maintenance follows a fault; it needs a justified basis where failure has safety consequences. These approaches can coexist on one asset.

Choose from the failure mode and required function, then test whether the method can reveal that failure in time. Routine servicing may improve availability without testing an emergency trip. A high percentage of completed tasks is weak reassurance if the tasks do not cover the credited protective functions.

How do preventive, predictive and corrective maintenance differ?

Use planned work to prevent known failure modes, condition evidence to detect emerging faults, and controlled repair to correct defects. The criticality of the barrier decides priority and permitted downtime.

Preventive work includes specified inspection, cleaning, replacement and functional checks before failure. Predictive or condition-based work uses relevant measurements such as vibration, temperature, leakage or wall thickness to identify degradation. Corrective work repairs an observed defect. A run-to-failure choice is only defensible if the item is not needed to prevent or mitigate a significant scenario and the consequences are understood. HSE COMAH plant design codes and monitoring and HSE COMAH maintenance procedures.

Maintenance mode and decision
Mode Example Decision and evidence
Preventive Inspect a transfer hose to an approved plan. Defined task, interval, competence and completion record.
Condition-based Trend corrosion thickness or pump vibration. Measurement method fits the damage mechanism; trend limit triggers action.
Corrective Repair a leaking seal or failed shutdown valve. Risk-rank the defect, hold or restrict plant, then verify the repaired function.
Run to failure A non-safety-critical indicator with safe redundancy. Only after documented consequence assessment; never assume this is acceptable for a credited barrier.

Applied case

A pump is serviced routinely, while its independent high-level shutdown has no recorded functional test.

Preventive

Planned work addresses a specified deterioration mechanism before its unacceptable state.

Condition-based

Monitoring must detect the relevant failure mechanism early enough to support a decision.

Test your decision

What is missing from the maintenance argument?

  1. Evidence that the specific shutdown function performs as required.
  2. Another routine lubrication entry.
  3. A cheaper servicing contractor.
Compare the explanation

Evidence that the specific shutdown function performs as required.

The strategy must cover the failure mode of the protective function, not merely the running equipment.

Open this interactive lesson →

LESSON 5

Know what inspection can show

Interpret an inspection result within its method, coverage and acceptance basis.

Closed pipework and vessels in a UK chemical processing plant. Photorealistic illustration.
Photorealistic illustrative UK workplace scene. Review checks: Setting: Transfer the correct fuel without overfill or loss of containment. Act: Confirm the stated prerequisites, current asset identity, barrier status and authorised work scope. Hold / review: Supervisor approval after any alarm, trip, bypass, unexplained level difference or changed transfer route.

Understand the decision

Inspection methods answer particular questions. A visual check can reveal some surface defects; a suitable non-destructive examination may investigate a credible concealed mechanism. Neither automatically assesses every part of a system. The report needs the correct asset identity, method, coverage, result and competent interpretation.

Compare findings with the applicable design and service basis through the responsible engineering route. Missing baseline information, inaccessible areas or an unexplained trend are limitations to record. A favourable result at one test point is not permission to disregard a different unexamined location.

How should inspection and non-destructive testing support integrity?

Inspection and NDT should target credible degradation mechanisms and produce evidence that can support continued safe operation.

NDT is valuable because it can reveal wall thinning, cracking, pitting, laminations, weld defects and other flaws without destroying equipment. But NDT is only useful when the technique is suitable for the expected defect and the inspection location is chosen intelligently.

A poor NDT programme can create false confidence. Sampling a small percentage of equipment only works if the inspected sample represents the uninspected items and the damage mechanism is likely to be distributed in a way that supports that assumption.

Inspection reports should not sit unreviewed. Findings should be trended, compared with expected degradation rates, used to update remaining-life assumptions and translated into repair, replacement or monitoring actions.

Inspection and NDT assurance questions - Inspection and NDT assurance questions
Question Good answer Weak signal
What damage is being sought? The inspection targets credible mechanisms for the service. Generic inspection scope copied from another asset.
Can the technique find it? NDT method is suitable for the defect type, size and location. Technique cannot detect expected cracking or CUI.
Are locations justified? Inspection points reflect damage likelihood and consequence. Only convenient or accessible areas are inspected.
Are results trended? Thickness, flaws and anomalies are compared over time. Reports are filed without engineering review.
Are actions closed? Repairs, restrictions or reinspection are tracked. Recommendations remain open past due date.
Is competence assured? Inspectors and reviewers are competent and independent where needed. No clear technical authority or challenge.
Sources and references

Sources for this explanation: HSE Inspection and non-destructive testing; HSE Mechanical Integrity Intervention Tool.

Applied case

A survey report has good readings at accessible points but excludes the wet support under insulation.

Coverage

A favourable reading establishes only what the method and examined area can support.

Excluded location

An unexamined wet support remains a visible limitation in the decision pack.

Test your decision

How should its limitation be treated?

  1. Use the best reading as the condition of the entire line.
  2. Keep the excluded location visible in the integrity decision and obtain competent follow-up.
  3. Delete the excluded location from the asset register.
Compare the explanation

Keep the excluded location visible in the integrity decision and obtain competent follow-up.

Coverage limits remain relevant. The report does not prove the condition of a location it did not examine.

Open this interactive lesson →

LESSON 6

Prove the safety function

Distinguish component servicing from testing the credited protective path.

Maintenance lock-off equipment on a UK machine isolator. Photorealistic illustration.
Photorealistic illustrative UK workplace scene. Review checks: Avoid / redesign: At design or change review, engineering considers removing the manual intervention or providing monitoring and maintainable access without opening a live process. Control the task: Competent staff specify the actual energy and material isolation, safe draining or cleaning, stored-energy control and any designed supports or physical separation. Verify before release: Check whether the redesign actually removes exposure or merely moves it to another task.

Understand the decision

A proof test challenges a defined safety function against its requirements. Depending on the design, the path can involve sensing, logic, power or utility supply and a final element. Servicing an actuator alone does not establish that the complete function reaches its required safe state.

The competent test plan defines scope, acceptance, safe test conditions and restoration. Record results, defects, unresolved limitations and the status of temporary test arrangements. A test record with no identified function or result is not proof; neither is an old successful result evidence of current availability after an unresolved fault.

Inspection and proof testing produce different evidence

Inspecting physical condition and testing a protective function address related but different failure modes.

Fictional learning example

Separate the evidence from the decision
Part of the pictureWhat the example establishes
Condition recordExternal inspection found no visible deterioration on a shutdown valve assembly.
Function recordThe specified complete-function test is overdue.
Operating decisionThe current restriction and authorised review route need to be established.

Pause and decide: Can the good visual inspection substitute for the overdue function test?

Compare the reasoning

No. Determine which failure mechanism and function each check addresses. Review the applicable performance standard, test scope, defects and temporary arrangements with the responsible roles. Do not invent an extension or treat a completed work order as evidence that the required function is available.

What is proof testing and what are its limits?

A proof test deliberately challenges a specified protective function to reveal dangerous hidden failures. It needs a controlled method, acceptance criteria and safe restoration of every bypass.

For a shutdown loop, specify the demand, sensor and logic response, valve travel or other final action, and required safe state. Plan the test so the plant remains protected; record any inhibited alarm or trip and who authorised it. A partial test may not demonstrate the full function. A failed test is an impaired barrier that needs an operating decision, not merely a maintenance job number. Test interval and scope come from the design basis and hazard analysis, not a universal number. HSE COMAH control systems and HSE COMAH maintenance procedures.

Keep as-found and as-left evidence

Illustrative proof-test record: shutdown valve/function and operating mode; required scope and coverage; as-found failure and open defect; repair; as-left result; bypasses restored; untested limitations; operating restriction; technical checker and named operational release. Keep the as-found failure after repair: it informs barrier reliability and cannot be erased by a passing as-left result or closed work order. No interval or live-plant method is implied.

Applied case

The valve travels on a local command; the automatic demand path was excluded from the test.

Local test

Valve travel alone does not demonstrate the automatic sensing and demand path.

Restoration

Testing is incomplete as an availability claim while required bypass removal or fault resolution remains open.

Test your decision

Which statement is defensible?

  1. The complete emergency isolation function has passed.
  2. Any proof-test interval can now be extended.
  3. Local movement was demonstrated; the untested demand path remains unproven.
Compare the explanation

Local movement was demonstrated; the untested demand path remains unproven.

Describe what was tested and what was not. Local movement cannot prove the omitted sensing and logic path.

Open this interactive lesson →

LESSON 7

Treat a backlog as a barrier issue

Explain why missed work and deferrals require an explicit decision.

Maintenance lock-off equipment on a UK machine isolator. Photorealistic illustration.
Photorealistic illustrative UK workplace scene. Review checks: Change at source: At design or change review, engineering considers removing the manual intervention or providing monitoring and maintainable access without opening a live process. Make it observable: Check whether the redesign actually removes exposure or merely moves it to another task. Keep useful evidence: Retain defect and leak history, risk and impairment decisions, isolation and permit record, repair specification, test result, valve proof-test closure, restart authorisation and overdue-work review.

Understand the decision

A backlog becomes meaningful when linked to the affected equipment, failure mode and barriers. Repeatedly moving a due date can conceal growing uncertainty. Review the reason, existing condition information, consequences, decision authority and the restrictions needed while the work remains open.

A routine business deferral is not a mechanism for overriding a statutory examination requirement. Determine applicable duties through competent advice. For ordinary maintenance decisions too, an extension needs a defensible technical basis, accountable approval and a controlled review point; lack of available labour is not evidence of fitness.

How should backlog and deferrals be controlled?

Rank overdue work by the scenario and barrier it affects. Escalate a safety-critical deferral before its due point becomes an unexamined acceptance of major-accident risk.

A backlog list needs asset identity, function, defect or task, due date, consequence, interim control, owner and review date. Count and age are useful, but an overdue emergency isolation valve can matter more than many low-risk jobs. A manager should challenge repeated deferrals, missing parts and temporary workarounds against actual operating conditions; shut down or restrict operations if barrier confidence is lost. HSE COMAH maintenance procedures and HSE HSG254 Developing process safety indicators.

Risk ranking a maintenance deferral
Signal Required decision Evidence
Safety-critical proof test overdue Identify the credited scenario and any overlap with other impaired barriers; decide restriction or shutdown. Named risk decision, interim measure, new date and management review.
Repeat defect after repair Investigate failure mode, repair quality and design; do not reset the clock. History, root cause, protected retest and closure.
Missing specialist spare Assess whether the barrier can meet its function; secure suitable replacement or restrict plant. Specification, procurement and impairment record.

Check the separate statutory boundary

Internal impairment approval does not extend a statutory examination date, override a prohibition or change the protective-function design basis. The deferral owner checks whether a separate statutory examination/postponement route applies; the pressure-system competent person’s responsibilities remain distinct from the manager’s operating decision.

Applied case

A planner is asked to move an overdue protective-valve test to make the dashboard show no overdue work.

Date edit

Moving a task does not restore the protective function or erase the original obligation.

Decision evidence

A deferral needs its applicable technical and legal basis, authority, restrictions and review condition.

Test your decision

What is the appropriate response?

  1. Keep the impairment visible and obtain a competent, authorised decision on the risk and work.
  2. Change the date without retaining the old due date.
  3. Close the task because the valve has not been demanded.
Compare the explanation

Keep the impairment visible and obtain a competent, authorised decision on the risk and work.

Changing a label does not restore a barrier. The unresolved test obligation and its consequences must remain visible.

Open this interactive lesson →

LESSON 8

Keep temporary repairs temporary

Recognise the conditions and limits of an engineered temporary repair.

2D teaching diagram: Link the permit to effective field controls
Existing SHAREhub 2D teaching schematic. Use alongside the explanation and fictional case in this lesson.

Understand the decision

A temporary repair is a technical change with a defined service, failure mechanism, design basis and life. It needs competent engineering assessment, authorisation, monitoring and a route to permanent resolution. Stopping a visible seep does not establish structural integrity or resistance to future loading.

Record the exact asset and repair boundary, restrictions and expiry or review conditions. Keep it linked to the defect and maintenance system so it cannot become invisible through repeated handovers. A repair that no longer meets its assessed conditions needs review; production pressure cannot broaden the original approval.

How should temporary repairs be controlled?

Temporary repairs should be engineered, time-limited, risk assessed and tracked to permanent resolution.

Temporary repairs may be necessary to maintain safe operation until shutdown or replacement, but they are a known source of integrity drift. A clamp, wrap, patch, bypass or restricted operating condition can become normal if it is not formally owned.

A temporary repair should have an engineering assessment, defined operating limits, inspection requirement, expiry date and permanent repair plan. It should be visible on the risk register and to operators.

If a temporary repair affects a safety-critical item or major accident barrier, the risk review should consider whether continued operation remains tolerable and whether additional safeguards are needed.

Temporary repair controls - Temporary repair controls
Requirement Purpose Evidence
Engineering approval Confirms repair method is suitable. Calculation, standard or competent review.
Risk assessment Considers consequence of failure and restrictions. Risk review and operating limits.
Time limit Prevents temporary becoming permanent by drift. Expiry date and permanent repair date.
Inspection plan Checks repair condition during service. Inspection frequency and records.
Operator briefing Ensures abnormal condition is understood. Shift briefing and control room note.
Management review Escalates overdue permanent repair. Backlog report and action owner.
Sources and references

Sources for this explanation: HSE Mechanical Integrity Intervention Tool.

Applied case

A clamp has stopped seepage, but its service restrictions and engineering record are missing.

Dry clamp

Stopping visible seepage is not the same as proving structural fitness.

Controlled life

Keep the assessed service, restrictions and review or expiry condition linked to the repair.

Test your decision

What should the team conclude?

  1. The clamp is permanent once it stays dry for a shift.
  2. The absence of visible seepage does not establish an authorised repair basis.
  3. The missing record can be replaced by a photograph of the clamp.
Compare the explanation

The absence of visible seepage does not establish an authorised repair basis.

Containment appearance and engineering justification are different evidence. Escalate the missing basis and control the affected operation.

Open this interactive lesson →

LESSON 9

Reassess changed service

Identify changes that can invalidate an integrity assumption.

2D teaching diagram: Keep the floating roof buoyant and aligned
Existing SHAREhub 2D teaching schematic. Use alongside the explanation and fictional case in this lesson.

Understand the decision

Changing composition, duty, temperature pattern or operating sequence may alter corrosion, seals, loading or inspection needs. A replacement that fits dimensionally can still differ in material or protective performance. The change process must examine the relevant system rather than only the purchased part.

Preserve the design basis and explain why the revised arrangement remains suitable. Update affected asset information, maintenance tasks and operating instructions before authorised return. Operators should report an unexpected change in behaviour; they should not solve an unexplained mismatch by adjusting limits or suppressing alarms.

How should management of change protect mechanical integrity?

MOC should catch changes that alter design intent, degradation mechanisms, inspection needs or barrier performance.

Many integrity failures begin with a change that looked small: new material, different chemical service, higher temperature, altered flow, temporary bypass, replacement part, changed inhibitor, new operating mode or deferred shutdown. MOC should ask whether the change affects equipment integrity before it is made.

The review should include drawings, materials of construction, design codes, operating envelope, relief protection, inspection scheme, maintenance strategy, procedures, training and emergency response.

Pre-start-up safety review matters after changes and repairs. Equipment should not return to service until required examinations, tests, documents, procedures and training are complete.

Integrity questions for management of change - Integrity questions for management of change
Change type Integrity question Evidence
Service change Does new chemistry, pressure or temperature create new degradation? Damage mechanism review.
Material substitution Is the replacement material suitable for service? Materials verification and approval.
Operating limit change Do relief, alarms and inspection intervals remain valid? Relief review and updated operating envelope.
Temporary bypass What barrier is weakened and what compensating measures exist? Bypass register and risk assessment.
Repair or replacement Has the item been tested and documented before start-up? Pre-start-up safety or readiness review, test certificate and updated records.
Organisational change Will competence, supervision or maintenance resource be affected? Organisational change risk review.
Sources and references

Sources for this explanation: HSE Mechanical Integrity Delivery Guide; HSE Mechanical Integrity Intervention Tool.

Applied case

A new solvent blend is proposed for a line whose seals and inspection plan were selected for the old product.

Changed material

A new blend can affect seals, corrosion and other assumptions without changing pipe dimensions.

Revised assurance

Change review must consider affected maintenance, inspection and operating information.

Test your decision

What needs review before accepting the change?

  1. Only whether the blend has a lower purchase price.
  2. Only the external dimensions of the pipe.
  3. Compatibility, degradation and affected controls for the new service.
Compare the explanation

Compatibility, degradation and affected controls for the new service.

The service change can affect integrity even when the equipment looks unchanged.

Open this interactive lesson →

LESSON 10

Plan work around the live plant

Connect maintenance scope to isolation and concurrent work.

Maintenance lock-off equipment on a UK machine isolator. Photorealistic illustration.
Photorealistic illustrative UK workplace scene. Review checks: Setting: the process operator must repair a leaking transfer-pump seal at a covered fuel terminal while an emergency shutdown valve proof test is overdue. Act: Stop transfer, restrict the affected line, check other credited barriers, choose a safe plant state, isolate and drain the pump, verify the boundary, and authorise the intrusive work only when controls are demonstrated. Hold / review: Hold the job or plant if inventory remains, isolation is uncertain, vapour conditions change, the shutdown valve cannot meet its function, or another barrier fails.

Understand the decision

Maintenance creates temporary plant states. Opening equipment can expose residual contents, trapped pressure or unexpected feeds, and taking a protective device out of service can affect an operating process elsewhere. Plan the work boundary, isolation, connected users and concurrent tasks before access.

Work permits and test arrangements coordinate the task but do not create physical safety by themselves. Stop when the equipment identity, isolation or credited barrier status is unresolved. Hand the discrepancy to the responsible site roles; an awareness learner is not authorised to improvise a method of opening or testing the system.

How is maintenance planned around a live process?

Plan the plant state and interfaces before access. Identify hazardous inventory, pressure, electricity, ignition sources, adjacent operations and the loss of any protection during the work.

Where practicable, perform intrusive work in a shutdown state. For necessary work near live plant, coordinate operations and maintenance, define isolation, draining, purging or flushing, atmospheric checks, permit boundaries and emergency arrangements. A permit records control; it does not replace correct isolation or competence. Protect against simultaneous operations and handovers, including contractors. HSE COMAH maintenance procedures and HSE maintenance of work equipment.

After repair, inspect the assembled equipment, remove temporary devices under control, confirm valve line-up and instrument settings, restore bypassed alarms and trips, carry out specified protected tests and authorise recommissioning. Wrong gaskets, reversed valves and left-out components can create a new initiating event.

Applied case

An actuator test is planned while a transfer still depends on the same valve for emergency isolation.

Dependent operation

Taking a valve out of service can remove protection from a transfer elsewhere.

Work boundary

The plan needs the actual equipment, credible feeds and controlled plant state.

Test your decision

Which question comes first?

  1. How will the affected transfer remain controlled while the function is unavailable?
  2. How can the test be hidden from the operations log?
  3. Can the maintainer finish before anyone notices?
Compare the explanation

How will the affected transfer remain controlled while the function is unavailable?

The dependent operation and temporary impairment must be included in work planning.

Open this interactive lesson →

LESSON 11

Verify hand-back, not just repair

Distinguish job completion from equipment readiness.

Closed pipework and vessels in a UK chemical processing plant. Photorealistic illustration.
Photorealistic illustrative UK workplace scene. Review checks: Avoid / redesign: Remove obsolete plant, redundant pipework or unnecessary hazardous inventory. Control the task: Segregate hazardous plant, use remote operation and protect people from rupture zones. Verify before release: Decommissioning records and inventory reduction.

Understand the decision

A completed repair order records work; operational hand-back needs evidence that the required condition and functions have been restored. Reconcile defects, inspection or test results, temporary configurations, permits, isolations and operating information through the site process. Some unresolved findings may prevent return.

Identify who accepts the equipment and who authorises the operating state. Communicate remaining restrictions to the next shift. A maintainer saying that a component is fitted is valuable information, but it does not establish that a system test, independent check or controlled restart has occurred.

What should be checked before, during and after integrity work?

Confirm the asset, hazard, design basis, barrier status, isolation, competent people and acceptance criteria before work; control change while it happens; then prove correct reinstatement and hand-back.

Integrity work checks and hold points
StageCheckHold or stop triggerEvidence
Before workMatch tag, drawing, service, pressure, temperature, material, contents and boundaries to the job.Identity, service history or drawing conflicts.Walkdown, marked drawing and job pack.
Before workConfirm isolation, drain, vent, purge, access, atmosphere, simultaneous operations and barrier impairments.Isolation cannot be proved or another barrier would be lost without an approved plan.Isolation certificate, permit and impairment record.
Before workDefine the expected damage, technique capability, coverage and acceptance criteria.Technique cannot detect or size the credible flaw.Inspection plan, procedure and competence evidence.
During workMonitor condition, process state, access, readings, unexpected indications and scope changes.Unexpected crack, wall loss, leak, vibration, contamination or limit excursion.Contemporaneous readings, photographs and deviation record.
During workProtect open systems, materials, cleanliness, traceability and removed safeguards.Foreign material, wrong component, lost traceability or uncontrolled barrier impairment.Parts record, hold-point release and material certificate.
Hand-backCheck assembly, torque, supports, guards, valves, instruments, leak tightness and housekeeping.Incomplete reinstatement, failed test or outstanding punch item affecting safety.Reinstatement checklist and test result.
RestartConfirm updated drawings, WSE or maintenance task, limits, alarms, bypasses, temporary controls and operator briefing.Documented basis and actual plant do not agree.Authorised hand-back, MOC close-out and shift brief.

Applied case

A replaced actuator is installed, but a test bypass remains open in the hand-back list.

Job complete

A work order establishes a task status, not automatic operating readiness.

Hand-back

Resolve configuration, results, temporary arrangements and the authorised acceptance of the plant state.

Test your decision

What prevents a simple return-to-service assumption?

  1. The replacement invoice has not been filed.
  2. The remaining bypass and required verification must be resolved through authorised hand-back.
  3. A local movement can be accepted as proof that no bypass remains.
Compare the explanation

The remaining bypass and required verification must be resolved through authorised hand-back.

A temporary bypass can defeat the credited function. Installation alone does not restore its availability.

Open this interactive lesson →

LESSON 12

Build an integrity decision pack

Combine mechanism, barrier status and accountable follow-up in a new case.

2D teaching diagram: Link the permit to effective field controls
Existing SHAREhub 2D teaching schematic. Use alongside the explanation and fictional case in this lesson.

Understand the decision

A defensible integrity decision connects the asset and hazard to condition evidence, maintenance requirements, current barrier status and an accountable operating decision. It distinguishes a confirmed defect from an unmeasured suspicion without dismissing either. Explain what is known, what remains uncertain and which restriction follows.

For transfer to your workplace, choose an asset within your role and ask how its next inspection or test is linked to a major-accident scenario. Use the fictional resource exercises to practise the evidence trail. Do not create real approvals or infer competence from completing this course.

How can leaders tell whether the strategy works?

Measure the condition of credited barriers and the quality of repair decisions, not just the percentage of completed work orders.

Sample overdue proof tests, failed-on-demand devices, unplanned releases, repeat defects, temporary repairs, backlog age by consequence, permit deviations and post-maintenance restoration. A leading indicator such as safety-critical actions completed to schedule should be paired with a lagging indicator such as loss of containment due to equipment failure. Investigate the meaning of an improving percentage if reporting or test scope has weakened. HSE HSG254 Developing process safety indicators.

Applied case

The blending manager has a wet line, an unproven trip and an expiring clamp record. The production order is urgent.

Combined impairments

A wet line, unproven trip and unsupported repair can weaken different barriers at once.

Transfer the method

Start with the next asset’s own service and failure scenario; do not copy intervals or limits.

Test your decision

Which response best integrates the evidence?

  1. Consider each item harmless because none has yet caused an injury.
  2. Restart after adding all three items to next month’s meeting agenda.
  3. Review the combined impaired barriers, restrict affected work and obtain verified resolution through the responsible roles.
Compare the explanation

Review the combined impaired barriers, restrict affected work and obtain verified resolution through the responsible roles.

Combined impairments can undermine several layers of protection. An action list does not itself justify operation.

Open this interactive lesson →