SHARE Knowledge Hub
Manganese poisoning
Inhaling manganese fume or fine dust can cause serious occupational harm. Identify the material and exposure route, control emissions at source and obtain competent occupational-health advice when exposure or symptoms raise concern.
Owner: SHARE Knowledge Hub editorial team.
Understanding Manganese poisoning
Manganese poisoning is a broad term for harmful effects of excess manganese exposure. In occupational practice the distinctive chronic concern is neurotoxicity, sometimes termed manganism, after repeated inhalation of manganese-containing dust or fume. The chapter also addresses acute respiratory symptoms and other constituents of welding fumes without attributing all welding illness to manganese.
Why this matters at work
A worker with balance trouble may have a range of causes. Occupational-health and neurological clinicians may evaluate the exposure chronology, clinical examination and other information as appropriate. Managers must not interpret an MRI image or a manganese measurement as proof or exclusion of illness.
The practical decision under uncertainty is to control a credible inhalation hazard now and obtain competent clinical review. Waiting for definitive causal attribution before repairing a failed LEV can prolong exposure for the whole group.
How organisations manage this in practice
Secure the source and prevent re-entry until a competent assessment identifies conditions for safe return. Review adjacent workers, maintenance crews and any public exposure. Record the event, conduct appropriate air or contamination measurements and verify controls before restart.
Review how the hazard was recognised: was the process-generated fume in the COSHH assessment, did LEV users report problems, and were measurements representative? Feed the answers into design and purchasing so the next process does not repeat the exposure pathway.
Review the COSHH assessment before change, ask whether LEV can capture the new geometry and whether RPE remains suitable. For powder handling, changes to moisture, packaging or transfer speed can alter dust generation and the relevant particle fractions.
An air result above the matching WEL, a trend toward it or symptoms among similarly exposed people needs competent investigation. Consider day-to-day variability and concurrent metal exposures. Do not attribute worker complaints to behaviour before checking whether the designed capture can work.
After the task, inspect deposits, check equipment restored and document any release. Sample representative maintenance work where needed; an eight-hour TWA comparison still requires sound duration and concentration data, while acute heavy release may need immediate containment regardless of the average.
Manganese is an essential dietary nutrient; ordinary food intake is not equivalent to breathing fine fume into the lungs. The relevant questions are the actual airborne form, concentration, duration, particle fraction, other metals and control performance, not the mere presence of manganese in a product.
Reassess capture when the welding position changes
Base material, consumable and the welding task influence fume. A hood that worked at one position can miss the source after the work or welder moves.

Identify the source
Establish the actual process, base material, coatings and consumables and their relevant information.
Control the route
Assess suitable capture, ventilation and residual protection for the working position and people nearby.
Verify performance
Use appropriate control/exposure evidence, including the relevant sampling fraction; hold a failed capture arrangement for competent correction.
Visible fume, a connected hose or a single area reading cannot establish personal exposure or a diagnosis.
What is manganese poisoning and where can it arise at work?
Manganese poisoning can occur when workplace exposure to manganese fume, dust or compounds is not adequately controlled, especially where inhalation of fine particles occurs.
Manganese is a metal used in steelmaking and present in many welding fumes, especially mild steel welding fume. It may also arise in foundry work, alloy production, grinding, cutting, thermal spraying, battery and catalyst work, pigment or chemical work, and maintenance tasks involving residues or contaminated dust. Sources: HSE health risks from welding; HSENI welding fume
The most important occupational route is inhalation of respirable particles and fume. Ingestion can also occur where contaminated hands, gloves, tools, cigarettes, food or welfare areas allow transfer to the mouth. Skin contact is less commonly the main toxic route for manganese itself, but contaminated skin and clothing can still drive ingestion and take-home contamination. Sources: HSE health risks from welding; HSENI welding fume
The health concern is not just short-term irritation. Repeated or high exposure can affect the nervous system. HSE welding guidance notes that manganese in mild steel welding fume has been associated with neurological symptoms similar to Parkinson's disease, including speech and balance disorders. Managers should not diagnose; they should prevent exposure and act early on reported symptoms. Sources: HSE health risks from welding; HSENI welding fume
A workplace exposure limit (WEL) is an air-exposure benchmark, not a diagnosis. Local exhaust ventilation (LEV) captures fume at source; respiratory protective equipment (RPE) addresses assessed residual exposure. The Control of Substances Hazardous to Health (COSHH) assessment must cover the real substance and task, while occupational health (OH) handles confidential health advice. Sources: HSE EH40 workplace exposure limits; HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI COSHH.
| Source or task | Main exposure route | Control focus |
|---|---|---|
| Mild steel welding | Respirable manganese-containing fume. | Avoid/reduce fume, on-torch extraction or LEV, suitable RPE and exposure monitoring.Sources: HSE health risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| Cutting or grinding manganese-containing metal | Fine dust and fume. | Wet methods where suitable, extraction, segregation and respiratory protection.Sources: HSE health risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| Foundry or ferro-alloy work | Dust, fume and contaminated surfaces. | Enclosure, ventilation, hygiene, cleaning and monitoring.Sources: HSE health risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| Battery or catalyst powders | Dust inhalation and hand-to-mouth transfer. | Containment, local extraction, closed handling and decontamination.Sources: HSE health risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| Maintenance or cleaning of contaminated plant | Disturbed settled dust and residues. | Planned isolation, controlled cleaning, RPE and waste route.Sources: HSE health risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| Poor welfare or hygiene | Ingestion and take-home contamination. | No food/drink in contaminated areas, washing, changing and laundering controls.Sources: HSE health risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
How does manganese exposure create harm?
Fine manganese-containing particles can be inhaled, absorbed and contribute to systemic effects, especially neurological effects, where exposure is repeated or high.
Manganese exposure should be assessed through substance form, particle size, task energy, ventilation, duration, frequency and control reliability. A small visible amount of fume can still contain respirable particles capable of reaching deep lung. Smell and visible smoke are poor measures of exposure. Sources: HSE health risks from welding; UKHSA manganese general information
The practical pathway is: manganese-containing task, fume or dust generation, inhalation or ingestion, uptake into the body, possible early symptoms or health effects, investigation of controls and competent medical or occupational health review where needed. Exposure prevention remains the main control. Sources: HSE health risks from welding; UKHSA manganese general information
| Step | What happens | Control or evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Substance present | Manganese is present in metal, fume, powder or residue. | SDS, material specification or process knowledge.Sources: HSE health risks from welding; UKHSA manganese general information |
| Task generates airborne exposure | Welding, cutting, grinding, pouring or cleaning produces fume/dust. | Task assessment and exposure monitoring.Sources: HSE health risks from welding; UKHSA manganese general information |
| Worker inhalation or ingestion | Respirable particles enter the lung or contamination reaches mouth. | LEV/RPE, hygiene and segregation.Sources: HSE health risks from welding; UKHSA manganese general information |
| Dose builds over time | Repeated exposure increases concern. | WEL comparison, duration tracking and control checks.Sources: HSE health risks from welding; UKHSA manganese general information |
| Health concern appears | Neurological, respiratory or general symptoms may be reported. | Confidential reporting and OH/medical signposting.Sources: HSE health risks from welding; UKHSA manganese general information |
| Control review | Work method and exposure controls are investigated. | COSHH review and corrective action.Sources: HSE health risks from welding; UKHSA manganese general information |
What does a manganese exposure signal prove—and what does it not?
Manganese can be present in welding fume and metal dust. Exposure, a workplace limit result and neurological symptoms are different kinds of information; none alone diagnoses manganism.
Separate manganese fractions
Read the complete visual as text
- Inhalable manganese: EH40: 0.2 mg/m³ as Mn, 8-hour time-weighted average. The inhalable fraction has its own sampling and comparison basis.
- Respirable manganese: EH40: 0.05 mg/m³ as Mn, 8-hour time-weighted average. Do not add or average the two fraction results together.
- Validated survey: Inhalable 0.14 mg/m³ is below its limit; respirable 0.06 mg/m³ exceeds its limit. Hold affected uncontrolled work, improve source control and obtain hygienist verification. Air results do not diagnose disease.
Manganese report: compare each relevant fraction separately
2 linked parts. Follow the question numbers and complete the applicable route.
Part 1 of 2 · Questions 1–3
Continue · Part 2 of 2 · Questions 4–6
Read the complete visual as text
- Start: A competent sampling report is presented for an exposure-control decision.
- Question 1: Is the personal sample representative of the real task? Decision owner: Occupational hygienist.
- YES: Review fraction, units and reference period. Owner: Occupational hygienist. CONTINUE → QUESTION 2.
- NO: No compliance conclusion: obtain representative sampling; an area sample cannot stand in for personal exposure. Owner: Occupational hygienist. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 1 AFTER CORRECTION.
- UNKNOWN: Keep the hold. No compliance conclusion: obtain representative sampling; an area sample cannot stand in for personal exposure. Owner: Occupational hygienist. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 1 AFTER CORRECTION.
- Question 2: Are fraction, as-Mn basis and 8-hour TWA verified? Decision owner: Occupational hygienist.
- YES: Compare each applicable fraction with its own WEL. Owner: Occupational hygienist. CONTINUE → QUESTION 3.
- NO: Hold the compliance conclusion and correct missing fraction, unit or period information. Owner: Occupational hygienist. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 2 AFTER CORRECTION.
- UNKNOWN: Keep the hold. Hold the compliance conclusion and correct missing fraction, unit or period information. Owner: Occupational hygienist. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 2 AFTER CORRECTION.
- Question 3: Are all fractions relevant to this assessment accounted for? Decision owner: Occupational hygienist.
- YES: Assess the inhalable result and then the respirable result separately. Owner: Occupational hygienist. CONTINUE → QUESTION 4.
- NO: Hold the conclusion; identify missing relevant fractions and the sampling needed. Owner: Occupational hygienist. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 3 AFTER CORRECTION.
- UNKNOWN: Keep the hold. Hold the conclusion; identify missing relevant fractions and the sampling needed. Owner: Occupational hygienist. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 3 AFTER CORRECTION.
- Question 4: Does inhalable manganese exceed 0.2 mg/m³ as Mn, 8-hour TWA? Decision owner: Occupational hygienist and task manager.
- YES: Protect people and hold affected uncontrolled work. Hygienist reassesses, corrects controls and verifies representative exposure evidence before a new comparison. Owner: Occupational hygienist and task manager. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 1 AFTER CORRECTION.
- NO: Retain controls and check the respirable result. Owner: Occupational hygienist and task manager. CONTINUE → QUESTION 5.
- NOT APPLICABLE: Hygienist records why inhalable measurement is not required for this assessed scenario. Owner: Occupational hygienist and task manager. CONTINUE → QUESTION 5.
- UNKNOWN: Hold the conclusion; obtain a verified inhalable result or competent scope reasoning. Owner: Occupational hygienist and task manager. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 4 AFTER CORRECTION.
- Question 5: Does respirable manganese exceed 0.05 mg/m³ as Mn, 8-hour TWA? Decision owner: Occupational hygienist and task manager.
- YES: Protect people and hold affected uncontrolled work. Hygienist reassesses, corrects controls and verifies representative exposure evidence before a new comparison. Owner: Occupational hygienist and task manager. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 1 AFTER CORRECTION.
- NO: Review task variation and co-exposures; this is not permanent clearance. Owner: Occupational hygienist and task manager. CONTINUE → QUESTION 6.
- NOT APPLICABLE: Hygienist records why respirable measurement is not required for this assessed scenario. Owner: Occupational hygienist and task manager. CONTINUE → QUESTION 6.
- UNKNOWN: Hold the conclusion; obtain a verified respirable result or competent scope reasoning. Owner: Occupational hygienist and task manager. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 5 AFTER CORRECTION.
- Question 6: Are actions, control verification and remaining limitations documented? Decision owner: Task manager with occupational hygienist.
- YES: Record the reasoned assessment and continuing controls/review. Owner: Task manager with occupational hygienist. OUTCOME → RECORD AND HAND OVER.
- NO: Keep affected work held where justified control is missing; obtain correction and verification evidence. Owner: Task manager with occupational hygienist. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 6 AFTER CORRECTION.
- UNKNOWN: Keep the hold. Keep affected work held where justified control is missing; obtain correction and verification evidence. Owner: Task manager with occupational hygienist. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 6 AFTER CORRECTION.
- Outcome: Document comparison, limitations, action and verification.
- Stop and escalation boundary: Fractions are not added or averaged together. An air result does not diagnose disease or establish that all welding fume is controlled.
HSE reports evidence that manganese in mild-steel welding fume may contribute to neurological symptoms resembling Parkinson’s disease. UKHSA describes dependence on dose, duration, form and route. New tremor, slowed movement, balance or mood change needs a clinician’s assessment and a confidential occupational-health route; managers should address work exposure and capability without diagnosing the person. HSE health risks from welding and UKHSA manganese general information.
For manganese and its inorganic compounds (as Mn), HSE EH40 lists eight-hour time-weighted-average workplace exposure limits of 0.2 mg/m³ for the inhalable fraction and 0.05 mg/m³ for the respirable fraction; the entry lists no separate 15-minute value. HSENI provides an approved EH40 route for NI, which a competent assessor should check against the applicable NI edition. These constituent-specific values are not a safe level for all welding fume or proof that extraction works. Measure representative real tasks and both relevant fractions where needed; never infer compliance from visibility alone. HSE EH40 workplace exposure limits, HSENI EH40 workplace exposure limits, HSE mild-steel welding-fume enforcement alert and HSENI welding fume.
| Signal | What it tells us | What is still needed | Action boundary |
|---|---|---|---|
| Visible fume or failed extraction | A control failure or exposure concern is plausible. | Material, process, capture and breathing-zone conditions. | Stop uncontrolled work; restore control and reassess.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| Air result against manganese WEL | One sampled fraction/exposure under stated method and period. | Inhalable versus respirable fraction, representativeness, worst-case tasks, other fume hazards and jurisdiction. | Competent hygiene interpretation; do not use it as an all-fume safe level.Sources: HSE EH40 workplace exposure limits; HSENI EH40 workplace exposure limits |
| Worker reports tremor or balance change | A health concern requiring timely, confidential clinical advice. | Clinical history and differential diagnosis; workplace exposure review. | Refer promptly; do not diagnose or demand private details.Sources: HSE welding-fume health surveillance; UKHSA manganese general information |
Control brief high exposures too
No listed manganese 15-minute value does not permit uncontrolled peaks. EH40 gives a three-times-long-term-limit guideline for short-term exposures where no STEL is specified; competent interpretation must consider the sampling period, task and relevant fraction. This is guidance, not a newly listed manganese STEL or universal safe ceiling. EH40 workplace exposure limits, fourth edition 2020.
How can the hierarchy of controls reduce manganese exposure and neurological harm?
Control the generation and spread of manganese-containing fume before relying on respiratory protection. The assessment needs the actual material, consumable, process and nearby workers; exposure evidence and clinical diagnosis are separate decisions.
Illustrative decision: a fabrication workshop welds a manganese-containing steel component. The welding engineer and occupational hygienist review the joining method and fume controls with operators before repeating the job.
ERICPD means Eliminate, Reduce (including substitution), Isolate, Control, PPE and Discipline. The five-level hierarchy groups measures as elimination, substitution, engineering controls, administrative controls and PPE. They overlap: isolation is usually an engineering measure; control can include engineered and administrative measures. Discipline means maintaining and checking the controls, supervising the method and learning from defects, rather than blaming someone or accepting weaker protection.
The comparison is an original illustrative application of the general HSE hierarchy, not a machine-specific method, permit or design approval. The employer must choose measures for the actual work and jurisdiction. Apply the separate Northern Ireland legal route where relevant; the local assessment and competent technical decision govern release.
How can welding fume exposure lead to manganese concern?
A welding example shows why visible fume, poor extraction and symptom reporting must be treated as control signals.
Follow the manganese source
Read the complete visual as text
- Five inputs to the fume: Identify base metal, wire or rod, flux, coating and process. The workpiece name alone does not establish the fume composition.
- Two exposure paths: Trace the plume towards the welder’s breathing zone and towards nearby workers. The visible plume is an explanatory overlay, not a measurement or a safe-distance boundary.
- Identity before control selection: Unknown consumable or coating means hold and obtain reliable information. Assess the actual task and select suitable source capture and residual protection.
Vessel welding: separate safety routes
Read the complete visual as text
- Avoid entry first: Consider remote inspection or external repair. If entry remains necessary, identify the applicable GB or NI confined-space route and competent site arrangements.
- Fume is one route: Engineered fume capture does not establish a breathable atmosphere. Shielding or purge gas can displace oxygen in low or connected spaces.
- Atmosphere, entry and rescue: Assess isolation, atmosphere checks from outside, ventilation, fire, access, attendant, communication and prepared trained rescue separately. Uncertain critical protection holds entry; reliance only on 999 is insufficient.
A fabrication team welds mild steel frames in a bay with general ventilation but no effective capture at source. Fume is visible around the breathing zone, and welders sometimes lift their visors while repositioning. One worker reports worsening hand tremor, balance concerns and unusual fatigue. The supervisor is unsure whether this is work-related and initially treats it as a personal medical issue. Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE health risks from welding
A stronger response removes the worker from further uncontrolled fume exposure while advice is sought, reviews COSHH assessment, checks manganese WEL relevance, arranges occupational hygiene monitoring, inspects extraction, reviews RPE suitability and face fit, and signposts confidential occupational health or medical advice. The review also checks whether others have similar exposure and whether the same work happens on other shifts. Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE health risks from welding
| Signal | Weak response | Better response |
|---|---|---|
| Visible fume in breathing zone | Accept as normal welding. | Review capture at source and exposure monitoring.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE health risks from welding |
| No local extraction | Rely on general ventilation. | Install/maintain LEV or on-torch extraction where suitable.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE health risks from welding |
| RPE used inconsistently | Tell welders to wear masks. | Assess RPE, face fit, supervision and work practicality.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE health risks from welding |
| Neurological symptoms reported | Ask for medical details informally. | Discuss work impact privately and signpost OH/medical advice.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE health risks from welding |
| One worker affected | Treat as isolated personal health issue. | Check exposure of similar workers and shifts.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE health risks from welding |
| Controls uncertain | Continue while investigating. | Restrict uncontrolled exposure and review COSHH controls.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE health risks from welding |
How should welding on high-manganese steel be controlled?
High-manganese steel work needs task-specific COSHH assessment because welding, gouging, cutting and grinding can generate respirable manganese-containing fume and dust.
A maintenance team repairs wear plates on quarry plant made from high-manganese steel. The job involves grinding old welds, air-arc gouging, welding repair runs and cleaning spatter inside a partially enclosed workshop bay. The team assumes this is ordinary fabrication work, but the consumables, base metal and task energy can all increase manganese-containing airborne contamination. Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE health risks from welding
A competent plan checks the material specification, welding consumable data and task sequence before work starts. It separates hot work from bystanders, captures fume at source, controls grinding dust, confirms general ventilation is not the primary exposure control, selects suitable RPE for residual exposure, sets hygiene and decontamination rules, arranges exposure monitoring where needed and defines symptom/OH escalation without asking managers to diagnose. Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE health risks from welding
| Work step | Exposure concern | Control and evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Confirm material and consumables | Manganese content may be higher than routine mild-steel work. | Material specification, SDS and welding procedure review.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE health risks from welding |
| Grind or gouge old welds | Fine dust and fume can enter the breathing zone. | On-tool extraction, segregation, eye/face protection and suitable RPE.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE health risks from welding |
| Weld repair runs | Respirable fume can exceed the WEL without effective controls. | LEV/on-torch extraction, airflow checks, RPE face fit and exposure monitoring.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE health risks from welding |
| Work in partial enclosure | Fume may accumulate and expose nearby workers. | Ventilation review, restricted access and bystander protection.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE health risks from welding |
| Clean residues | Dry sweeping can re-suspend settled contamination. | Class-rated vacuum or wet cleaning, waste route and hygiene controls.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE health risks from welding |
| Worker reports tremor/balance concern | Possible health signal needing competent review. | Remove from uncontrolled exposure, review COSHH controls and signpost OH/medical advice.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE health risks from welding |
| Repeat similar jobs | Exposure group may extend beyond one worker. | Similar exposure group review and control standard update.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE health risks from welding |
What control standard should be expected for manganese fume and dust?
The control standard should prevent or adequately control exposure at source before relying on RPE.
For welding and hot work, the strongest controls include eliminating unnecessary welding, using lower-fume processes or consumables where practicable, capturing fume at source, enclosing or segregating high-fume work, maintaining extraction, and using suitable RPE for residual exposure. RPE is important, but it should not be used to disguise poor fume control. Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume
For powders and residues, containment, closed transfer, local extraction, wet or vacuum cleaning, hygiene, waste control and contaminated clothing arrangements become central. Dry sweeping and compressed-air cleaning can turn settled contamination into inhalable exposure. Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume
| Control area | Good practice | Common failure |
|---|---|---|
| Substitution/process | Reduce fume generation where practicable. | Assume welding method is fixed.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| Capture at source | LEV or on-torch extraction captures fume before breathing zone. | General ventilation relied on alone.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| Segregation | High-fume work separated from others. | Nearby workers exposed as bystanders.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| RPE | Suitable, maintained and supervised; face-fit tested where a tight-fitting face seal is used. | Masks issued without fit or compatibility check.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| Cleaning | Class-rated vacuum or wet cleaning where suitable. | Dry sweeping or compressed air.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| Hygiene | Hand washing, clean welfare and no eating in contaminated areas. | Contaminated gloves/tools enter welfare.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
Match RPE checks to the design
Face-fit testing applies to RPE with a tight-fitting face seal. Loose-fitting powered equipment still needs suitable selection, maintenance and use checks; do not assume every respirator design needs the same face-fit process.
How should symptom reporting and health surveillance be handled?
Managers should act on exposure and work impact while competent health professionals handle medical assessment.
Symptoms need a clinical route
Read the complete visual as text
- Immediate danger: Illness or suspected exposure needs appropriate prompt help through the site first-aid or emergency arrangements. Do not delay urgent protection to complete records.
- Clinical care: New movement, balance, speech, mood or memory concerns need prompt qualified clinical assessment. Provide the exposure history; a checklist or one air or urine result cannot diagnose manganism.
- Employer control: Protect from uncontrolled exposure and review controls for others sharing the task. The employer receives proportionate functional and control advice, with clinical details kept confidential.
Symptoms: health care and exposure control remain separate
Read the complete visual as text
- URGENT ACUTE ILLNESS: Use the actual emergency/first-aid arrangement and safe withdrawal from uncontrolled exposure; do not wait for an ordinary referral.
- CLINICAL CONCERN: New movement, balance, speech, mood or memory concerns need prompt qualified medical/OH assessment; the clinician considers alternative causes.
- WORK EXPOSURE: The manager protects the worker from further uncontrolled exposure and reviews controls, monitoring and similarly exposed workers.
- CONFIDENTIAL ADVICE: Clinical detail remains confidential; the employer needs proportionate work/capability advice and a review, not an unsupported diagnosis.
Potential manganese-related symptoms may include movement, balance, speech, mood, memory or fatigue concerns, but these symptoms can have many causes. A manager should not diagnose, speculate or record unnecessary medical detail. Sources: HSE welding-fume health surveillance; HSENI COSHH
The workplace response is to protect the worker from further uncontrolled exposure, review the COSHH controls, signpost occupational health or medical advice, and check whether similar workers may have been exposed. Health surveillance should be based on risk assessment and competent occupational health advice. Sources: HSE welding-fume health surveillance; HSENI COSHH
| Do | Do not | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Ask what work tasks are affected. | Ask for detailed diagnosis or test results casually. | Protects privacy and keeps focus on work risk.Sources: HSE welding-fume health surveillance; HSENI COSHH |
| Review exposure controls immediately. | Wait for a confirmed medical diagnosis. | Exposure prevention should not be delayed.Sources: HSE welding-fume health surveillance; HSENI COSHH |
| Signpost OH/GP/urgent care where appropriate. | Give medical opinions. | Keeps decisions within competence.Sources: HSE welding-fume health surveillance; HSENI COSHH |
| Record work actions and referrals. | Record speculative health conclusions. | Supports data protection and trust.Sources: HSE welding-fume health surveillance; HSENI COSHH |
| Check similar exposure groups. | Treat one report as only personal. | Identifies wider control failure.Sources: HSE welding-fume health surveillance; HSENI COSHH |
When should manganese-related work stop or escalate?
Stop or escalate when visible fume/dust, failed extraction, uncertain WEL compliance, symptoms or contaminated welfare suggest exposure is not controlled.
Capture at the actual workface
Read the complete visual as text
- Source moves, hood stays: As a weld progresses, a poorly placed hood can leave the fume path through the worker’s breathing zone and towards a colleague even while the fan runs.
- Capture follows the source: Use suitable on-torch or repositioned capture within the assessed method. Check hood position, worker head position, airflow and nearby exposure.
- Failure means hold: Uncaptured fume or failed airflow stops the affected task. Correct and verify actual capture; RPE selection and use require the competent COSHH route.
Dust plant maintenance and hand-back
Read the complete visual as text
- Normal containment: Keep manganese-bearing dust enclosed and captured in the transfer and collector system. Include nearby workers and maintenance exposure.
- Filter change: Use the planned isolation and contained removal method, suitable protection and sealed waste. A damaged filter bag stops the task; do not dry sweep or use compressed air to spread dust.
- Verified return: Correct the defect, clean by the assessed method and check LEV performance under actual conditions. Record named hand-back before restarting dust-producing work.
Manganese task: controlled start or hold
2 linked parts. Follow the question numbers and complete the applicable route.
Part 1 of 2 · Questions 1–3
Continue · Part 2 of 2 · Questions 4–6
Read the complete visual as text
- Start: A proposed task may generate manganese-containing fume or dust.
- Question 1: Are base material, consumable, flux and coating identified? Decision owner: Supervisor and COSHH assessor.
- YES: Assess the actual emission source and people exposed. Owner: Supervisor and COSHH assessor. CONTINUE → QUESTION 2.
- NO: Hold disturbance and obtain reliable material and consumable information. Owner: Supervisor and COSHH assessor. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 1 AFTER CORRECTION.
- UNKNOWN: Keep the hold. Hold disturbance and obtain reliable material and consumable information. Owner: Supervisor and COSHH assessor. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 1 AFTER CORRECTION.
- Question 2: Is the assessment current for this task and GB or NI site? Decision owner: Competent COSHH assessor.
- YES: Use the applicable assessment and source-control method. Owner: Competent COSHH assessor. CONTINUE → QUESTION 3.
- NO: Hold work and complete the task- and territory-specific assessment. Owner: Competent COSHH assessor. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 2 AFTER CORRECTION.
- UNKNOWN: Keep the hold. Hold work and complete the task- and territory-specific assessment. Owner: Competent COSHH assessor. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 2 AFTER CORRECTION.
- Question 3: Does source control capture the actual workface? Decision owner: Supervisor and LEV/engineering owner.
- YES: Check residual exposure and affected neighbours. Owner: Supervisor and LEV/engineering owner. CONTINUE → QUESTION 4.
- NO: Hold fume/dust generation; correct capture, containment or extraction and verify at the task. Owner: Supervisor and LEV/engineering owner. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 3 AFTER CORRECTION.
- UNKNOWN: Keep the hold. Hold fume/dust generation; correct capture, containment or extraction and verify at the task. Owner: Supervisor and LEV/engineering owner. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 3 AFTER CORRECTION.
- Question 4: Is required residual RPE suitable and ready for its users? Decision owner: Supervisor and competent RPE adviser.
- YES: Retain source control and check nearby people. Owner: Supervisor and competent RPE adviser. CONTINUE → QUESTION 5.
- NO: Hold affected work; resolve suitability and use through competent assessment. Owner: Supervisor and competent RPE adviser. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 4 AFTER CORRECTION.
- UNKNOWN: Keep the hold. Hold affected work; resolve suitability and use through competent assessment. Owner: Supervisor and competent RPE adviser. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 4 AFTER CORRECTION.
- Question 5: Are bystanders, hygiene and emergency arrangements protected? Decision owner: Supervisor.
- YES: Verify the controlled method at the workface. Owner: Supervisor. CONTINUE → QUESTION 6.
- NO: Hold work and resolve exposure, contamination or response gaps. Owner: Supervisor. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 5 AFTER CORRECTION.
- UNKNOWN: Keep the hold. Hold work and resolve exposure, contamination or response gaps. Owner: Supervisor. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 5 AFTER CORRECTION.
- Question 6: Is fume/dust uncontrolled, extraction failed or a serious symptom reported? Decision owner: Supervisor.
- YES: Stop affected work and use the appropriate emergency or specialist response. Owner: Supervisor. STOP / REFER → APPROPRIATE RESPONSE.
- NO: Named supervisor may accept the assessed controlled start and monitor change. Owner: Supervisor. OUTCOME → RECORD AND HAND OVER.
- UNKNOWN: Hold the task; obtain competent hygiene, engineering or health advice for the unresolved condition. Owner: Supervisor. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 6 AFTER CORRECTION.
- Outcome: Record controlled start or continued hold, owner and change triggers.
- Stop and escalation boundary: Fume capture does not settle confined-space atmosphere, entry, fire or rescue: those retain separate competent safety routes.
Failed extraction: keep the source held until verified
2 linked parts. Follow the question numbers and complete the applicable route.
Part 1 of 2 · Questions 1–3
Continue · Part 2 of 2 · Questions 4–6
Read the complete visual as text
- Start: LEV airflow or capture is lost during manganese fume/dust work.
- Question 1: Is fume or dust generation safely stopped? Decision owner: Supervisor.
- YES: Protect nearby people and keep the task held. Owner: Supervisor. CONTINUE → QUESTION 2.
- NO: Stop the source through the safe site method; do not enter uncontrolled exposure. Owner: Supervisor. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 1 AFTER CORRECTION.
- UNKNOWN: Keep the hold. Stop the source through the safe site method; do not enter uncontrolled exposure. Owner: Supervisor. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 1 AFTER CORRECTION.
- Question 2: Are nearby people protected from the uncontrolled source? Decision owner: Supervisor.
- YES: Maintain restriction while engineering investigates. Owner: Supervisor. CONTINUE → QUESTION 3.
- NO: Restrict affected work/access and address neighbours and contamination. Owner: Supervisor. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 2 AFTER CORRECTION.
- UNKNOWN: Keep the hold. Restrict affected work/access and address neighbours and contamination. Owner: Supervisor. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 2 AFTER CORRECTION.
- Question 3: Has a competent person identified the cause of lost capture? Decision owner: LEV/engineering owner.
- YES: Select repair or a competent assessed alternative. Owner: LEV/engineering owner. CONTINUE → QUESTION 4.
- NO: Keep the hold and investigate hood, duct, filter, fan and work position. Owner: LEV/engineering owner. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 3 AFTER CORRECTION.
- UNKNOWN: Keep the hold. Keep the hold and investigate hood, duct, filter, fan and work position. Owner: LEV/engineering owner. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 3 AFTER CORRECTION.
- Question 4: Is an alternative controlled method proposed? Decision owner: Competent COSHH assessor.
- YES: Assess suitability and exposure controls before accepting the alternative; an untested mask is insufficient. Owner: Competent COSHH assessor. CONTINUE → QUESTION 5.
- NO: Repair the failed system and verify it before hand-back. Owner: Competent COSHH assessor. CONTINUE → QUESTION 5.
- UNKNOWN: Keep the source held until the responsible owner establishes the method. Owner: Competent COSHH assessor. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 4 AFTER CORRECTION.
- Question 5: Has effective control been verified under actual task conditions? Decision owner: Engineering owner with hygienist.
- YES: Provide the test and task evidence to the named release owner. Owner: Engineering owner with hygienist. CONTINUE → QUESTION 6.
- NO: Keep the hold; repair, re-position or redesign and re-test capture. Owner: Engineering owner with hygienist. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 5 AFTER CORRECTION.
- UNKNOWN: Keep the hold. Keep the hold; repair, re-position or redesign and re-test capture. Owner: Engineering owner with hygienist. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 5 AFTER CORRECTION.
- Question 6: Has the responsible owner accepted documented hand-back? Decision owner: Named task release owner.
- YES: Brief users and record controlled restart and change triggers. Owner: Named task release owner. OUTCOME → RECORD AND HAND OVER.
- NO: Keep affected work held while effective control or responsible release is missing. Owner: Named task release owner. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 6 AFTER CORRECTION.
- UNKNOWN: Keep the hold. Keep affected work held while effective control or responsible release is missing. Owner: Named task release owner. HOLD → REPEAT QUESTION 6 AFTER CORRECTION.
- Outcome: Document verified restart or continued hold.
- Stop and escalation boundary: No specific RPE selection, engineering performance value or confined-space release is supplied.
Supervisors should have clear stop points for manganese-containing work. If extraction is not working, RPE is unsuitable, dust is uncontrolled, workers report relevant symptoms or monitoring suggests exposure may exceed limits, work should pause or move into a controlled method. Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume
Escalation should involve occupational hygiene, occupational health, engineering and management support as needed. The aim is to control exposure, not to prove illness. Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume
| Trigger | Immediate action | Evidence before normal work |
|---|---|---|
| Visible fume in breathing zone | Review capture and restrict exposure. | LEV/RPE check and exposure assessment.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| LEV or on-torch extraction failed | Stop affected work or use competent temporary control. | Repair, test and user briefing.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| Dry dust cleaning occurring | Stop and change cleaning method. | Safe cleaning method and waste route.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| Worker reports neurological symptoms | Discuss privately, reduce exposure and signpost competent advice. | OH/medical route and COSHH review.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| Monitoring indicates high exposure | Review process and controls urgently. | Corrective action and repeat monitoring.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| Contamination reaches welfare | Clean, segregate and review hygiene controls. | Welfare inspection and behaviour check.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
Where do manganese controls fail?
They fail when fume or dust is normalised, exposure is not measured and RPE is treated as the whole control strategy.
The most common weakness is accepting visible welding fume as inevitable. Another is treating mild steel welding as low concern because stainless steel or galvanised work feels more obviously hazardous. Manganese risk can sit inside routine mild steel work. Sources: HSE WL3 welding-fume control; HSENI welding fume
Good control asks whether fume is generated, where it goes, who breathes it, whether exposure is below the relevant WEL, whether controls are maintained and whether workers can report symptoms without stigma. Sources: HSE WL3 welding-fume control; HSENI welding fume
| Failure or weak practice | How it develops | What good looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Fume accepted as normal | Workers breathe visible fume daily. | Capture fume at source and monitor exposure.Sources: HSE WL3 welding-fume control; HSENI welding fume |
| RPE-only strategy | Engineering controls are weak or absent. | Improve process, LEV and segregation first.Sources: HSE WL3 welding-fume control; HSENI welding fume |
| No exposure monitoring | WEL compliance is assumed. | Use competent occupational hygiene assessment.Sources: HSE WL3 welding-fume control; HSENI welding fume |
| Poor maintenance | Extraction flow falls over time. | Routine checks, TExT where applicable and defect action.Sources: HSE WL3 welding-fume control; HSENI welding fume |
| Hygiene failure | Dust transfers to hands, food or vehicles. | Clean welfare, washing and clothing controls.Sources: HSE WL3 welding-fume control; HSENI welding fume |
| Symptoms ignored | Worker concerns are treated as unrelated. | Act on work exposure and signpost health advice.Sources: HSE WL3 welding-fume control; HSENI welding fume |
Distinguish routine checks from periodic examination
TExT means thorough examination and test. For the GB welding LEV example, distinguish daily damage/performance checks and prompt repair from competent examination/test at intervals no longer than 14 months; retain examination/test records for at least five years. A recent certificate cannot release welding after capture fails. NI uses its separate COSHH route. HSE: maintaining welding controls.
What evidence shows manganese exposure is controlled?
Evidence should show that manganese sources are understood, exposure is assessed, controls are maintained and health concerns are escalated properly.
Useful evidence includes COSHH assessment, SDS or material data, welding consumable information, task observations, exposure monitoring, WEL comparison, LEV examination and maintenance, RPE face-fit records, cleaning standards, hygiene inspections, health surveillance decisions and occupational health referral routes. Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI COSHH
Evidence should be task-specific. A general welding policy does not prove manganese exposure is controlled for a welder working inside a poor-ventilated fabrication bay. Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI COSHH
| Evidence item | What it should show | Assurance question |
|---|---|---|
| COSHH substance and task review | Manganese-containing fume, dust, powders or residues are identified. | Does the assessment cover the actual welding or dust task?Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI COSHH |
| Exposure monitoring | Air monitoring or competent assessment checks whether WELs may be exceeded. | Are results linked to tasks and controls?Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI COSHH |
| Health and hygiene controls | Workers have suitable welfare, reporting and OH routes. | Are privacy and symptom escalation controlled?Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI COSHH |
| Risk assessment | Assessment describes the actual task, people affected, credible harm routes, controls and review triggers. | Compare against work as done, not only the written method.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI COSHH |
| Control standard | The required control is defined in operational terms. | Workers and supervisors can explain what must be in place before work starts.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI COSHH |
| Competence and briefing | People have suitable instruction, training, supervision and authorisation where needed. | Competence is checked through observed practice, not attendance alone.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI COSHH |
| Monitoring and defect action | Checks find weak signals, defects and non-compliance early. | Actions are risk-ranked, owned and closed with evidence.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI COSHH |
| Management review | Leaders review trends, repeat findings, high-risk actions and resource needs. | Decisions and learning are recorded.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI COSHH |
Record the capture failure and restoration
Illustrative record: weld/process and hood; expected capture/performance; observed damage or failed capture; restriction; competent repair owner; due date; examination basis; passing restoration evidence and named release.
How should manganese controls be assured?
Assurance should test exposure at the task, control performance, worker behaviour and health-related weak signals.
First-line assurance includes checking fume capture, RPE use, cleaning and hygiene during work. Second-line assurance reviews monitoring, LEV records, defect closure, exposure groups and symptom reports. Specialist assurance may require occupational hygienists, occupational health and welding engineers. Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE welding-fume health surveillance
A strong assurance question is: where is the fume going before it reaches the welder's breathing zone? Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE welding-fume health surveillance
| Level | What to check | What good looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Frontline check | Workers and supervisors confirm that manganese exposure controls are present, understood and suitable before work starts. | Work stops when critical controls are missing, defeated or unclear.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE welding-fume health surveillance |
| Manager review | Managers review open actions, repeat defects, competence gaps, incidents, health signals and work-as-done feedback. | Resources and deadlines match the seriousness of the risk.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE welding-fume health surveillance |
| Competent review | Specialists review technical, medical, fire, security, ergonomic or machinery complexity. | Advice is converted into practical controls and review dates.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE welding-fume health surveillance |
| Leadership assurance | Senior leaders review high-consequence risks, overdue actions and weak signals. | Governance tests control effectiveness, not just document completion.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSE welding-fume health surveillance |
Which GB and NI exposure duties apply to manganese work?
Great Britain uses COSHH 2002; Northern Ireland uses separate COSHH (NI) 2003. Both routes require assessment and adequate exposure control, with monitoring and health surveillance when their legal tests are met.
In Great Britain (GB), the 1974 Act and Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations 2002 frame the employer’s assessment and control duty. In Northern Ireland (NI), the 1978 Order and COSHH (NI) 2003 are separate instruments. HSE and HSENI guidance distinguish the legal duty from process-specific ways to control welding fume. A GB regulation number is not an NI citation. Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974, Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations 2002, Health and Safety at Work (NI) Order 1978, Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations (NI) 2003, HSE controlling the risks from welding and HSENI COSHH.
| Decision | Great Britain | Northern Ireland | Workplace proof |
|---|---|---|---|
| Assess hazardous substance and route | COSHH 2002 assessment and control. | Separate COSHH (NI) 2003 assessment and control. | Materials, fume/dust generation, exposed people and task-specific controls.Sources: Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations 2002; Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations (NI) 2003 |
| Constituent exposure limits | HSE EH40 manganese as Mn: inhalable 0.2 mg/m³ and respirable 0.05 mg/m³, both eight-hour TWA. | Use HSENI-approved EH40 route with NI COSHH; confirm applicable fractions and edition. | Competent representative exposure assessment, not visual guess or single safe number.Sources: HSE EH40 workplace exposure limits; HSENI EH40 workplace exposure limits |
| Control, monitoring and surveillance | Prevent or adequately control, maintain controls; monitor and surveil where required. | Separate NI duties and HSENI guidance. | Functional LEV/RPE, monitoring decision and confidential OH pathway.Sources: Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations 2002; Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations (NI) 2003 |
Voluntary-standard detail on hold
Specific standard editions, clauses and derived management-system detail are withheld until authorised text, rights and competent technical review are complete. Use applicable law and verified site evidence for current decisions.
For general health and safety management, see HSE managing health and safety.
What training and competence are needed?
Training should cover where manganese exposure arises, why welding fume matters, how extraction and RPE work, hygiene standards, symptom reporting and stop-work triggers.
Training should be role-based. General awareness creates a baseline, but supervisors, managers, advisers and senior leaders need different levels of decision-making, verification and escalation competence. Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume
| Level | Who it is for | What it should cover |
|---|---|---|
| General awareness | All workers who may be affected by the topic. | Plain-English overview of manganese exposure control, why it matters, early warning signs, basic reporting routes and where to find support or guidance.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| Task-specific practical training | Workers who carry out the activity or face the exposure. | Real tasks, equipment, decision points, stop triggers, pre-use checks, emergency response and practical scenarios.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| Supervisor and line manager training | People who plan work, allocate staff, check controls or respond to concerns. | How to brief work, verify controls, challenge drift, protect confidentiality where relevant and escalate when conditions change.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| HSE, HR, OH or technical adviser coordination | Advisers who support the system. | Legal boundaries, records, assurance checks, trend review, referral quality, evidence standards and action tracking.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
| Specialist competence | Use occupational hygienists, occupational health, welding engineers, LEV specialists and competent COSHH advisers where exposure level, neurological symptoms or control adequacy is uncertain. | Competent assessment, technical review, design, inspection, audit, occupational health or engineering support where ordinary management competence is not enough.Sources: HSE controlling the risks from welding; HSENI welding fume |
What do the acronyms and key terms mean?
These terms distinguish a legal exposure limit, engineering control and clinical route.
| Term | Full name | Meaning here |
|---|---|---|
| COSHH | Control of Substances Hazardous to Health | Separate GB 2002 and NI 2003 rules. Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations 2002; Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations (NI) 2003 |
| WEL | Workplace exposure limit | Airborne constituent benchmark for a stated averaging period; not an all-fume safe level. HSE health risks from welding |
| LEV | Local exhaust ventilation | Capture fume or dust at source. HSE controlling the risks from welding |
| RPE | Respiratory protective equipment | Residual inhalation protection selected for the task. HSE controlling the risks from welding |
| OH | Occupational health | Confidential competent health and work-capability advice. HSE welding-fume health surveillance |
| PPE | Personal protective equipment | Residual protection after stronger controls. HSE managing risk using PPE |
| ERICPD | Eliminate, Reduce, Isolate, Control, PPE, Discipline | A control-selection aid; sustain controls through supervision, maintenance and learning. It creates no separate legal duty. |
Unlock another resource
You have used this month’s two free downloads. Publish a post in your own words to unlock one more resource, or choose SHARE Individual for 10 downloads per month.
You decide whether to share. If you do, use the relevant platform disclosure tools and do not make claims you do not genuinely hold.