SHARE Knowledge Hub

Qualified Duties in Statute Law

Health and safety legislation sets different standards for how far a duty holder must go. An absolute requirement must be met where it applies; “practicable” asks whether a measure can be done; “so far as is reasonably practicable” weighs risk against the sacrifice of further protection. The distinction matters when selecting controls and explaining why a safety measure was or was not taken.

Updated 2026-10-19Great Britain and Northern IrelandVersion 3.3 · review candidate

Understanding Qualified Duties in Statute Law

Health and safety legislation sets different standards for how far a duty holder must go. An absolute requirement must be met where it applies; “practicable” asks whether a measure can be done; “so far as is reasonably practicable” weighs risk against the sacrifice of further protection. The distinction matters when selecting controls and explaining why a safety measure was or was not taken.

Why this matters at work

Hypothetical GB major-hazard task: a credible low-frequency release could affect many people, and a retrofit isolation valve has substantial cost. For an establishment within COMAH’s scope, regulation 5 requires the operator to take all measures necessary to prevent major accidents and limit consequences for human health and the environment, and to demonstrate the specified measures to the competent authority. A single unfavourable cost/fatality calculation does not itself demonstrate those requirements. Confirm COMAH scope separately.

GB COSHH regulation 6 prohibits liable-exposure work until a suitable/sufficient assessment AND required steps are implemented; it specifies content, regular/forthwith review triggers and the five-employee recording condition. Regulation 7 requires prevention OR, where not reasonably practicable, adequate control through its ordered measures. Adequacy requires Schedule 2A principles, applicable WEL compliance AND the specified carcinogen/mutagen/asthmagen exposure reduction to as low as reasonably practicable. A WEL alone is not the complete adequacy test. NI has separate COSHH law.

How organisations manage this in practice

GB CDM 2015 duties attach to actual project roles. Regulations 4/5/8 address client arrangements, timely written principal appointments when more than one contractor is or foreseeably will be involved, and role capability/cooperation. Regulation 7 reallocates specified domestic-client duties and provides default principal roles. Designer 9 requires foreseeable design-risk elimination so far as reasonably practicable, then the specified reduction/control and information routes; its paragraph 4 uses all reasonable steps for sufficient design information. NI CDM law is separate.

GB and NI Management regulation 5 separately require employers to make AND give effect to arrangements appropriate to the nature of activities and undertaking size for effective planning, organisation, control, monitoring and review of preventive/protective measures. Employers with five or more employees record those arrangements. The appropriate-arrangements duty is not limited to that size threshold, and a recorded manual does not by itself show arrangements given effect.

Use the operative GB or NI provision and its effective date. GB employer sections 2/3 and proof section 40 are not the NI statutory references: NI employer articles 4/5 and proof article 37 are separately linked. Record dutyholder, protected persons, trigger, act/result, qualifier, exception and sector scope. Article 43 civil liability also differs from GB section 47; avoid UK-wide conclusions from one jurisdiction’s text.

Start with the exact provision and jurisdiction

Absolute, practicable and reasonably practicable duties are legal tests, not levels in a control pyramid. The wording and context of the actual provision matter.

Safety professional reviewing guidance and documents in a UK workplace office. Photorealistic illustration.
Illustrative UK workplace scene. Read the practical checks below for responsibilities, evidence and limits. Download image · Download smaller image
  1. Identify the duty

    Establish the jurisdiction, exact provision, duty holder and relevant activity before choosing the test.

  2. Apply the correct test

    Keep each legal qualification distinct and obtain competent interpretation where uncertain; do not invent a numerical gross-disproportion factor.

  3. Connect evidence to the work

    Identify the actual risk, feasible measures and evidence about the control in use. A smaller vehicle does not remove crush risk.

  4. Record and review

    The accountable owner records the reasoned decision, implementation and field verification; a legal label alone is not a release decision.

Read the complete task-specific control examples

ERICPD is a planning cross-map: Discipline verifies and sustains every control. ESEAP compares effectiveness. A label does not authorise the task; retain the owner, evidence and stop or change decision.

Qualified Duties in Statute Law · ERICPD

Eliminate
At BuildOut, change the delivery route or vehicle movement so the lorry drives through rather than reverses across the leisure-centre path. Project and venue managers should test geometry, loading need and public access; if drive-through is infeasible, record the physical reason before considering lower controls.
Reduce
Choose a vehicle and delivery arrangement that can use a safer gate or shorter manoeuvre only if load, turning radius, stability and other traffic remain suitable. A smaller lorry does not remove crush energy or make pedestrian contact acceptable.
Isolate
Install a robust barrier and controlled pedestrian diversion between the reverse zone and leisure-centre access; protect the crossing and accessible route, not just paint a line. This physically breaks the vehicle–person contact path.
Control
Fit and maintain suitable mirrors, cameras, lighting or alarm on the selected lorry where needed; these assist visibility but do not replace the barrier. Set delivery windows, driver route and a trained marshal standing in a safe position as residual administrative controls.
PPE
Specify high-visibility clothing for authorised workers who may be near the controlled route. Check size, condition and lighting performance. It may help the driver see a person but cannot resist a vehicle impact or admit pedestrians into the exclusion zone.
Discipline
Brief drivers, contractors and venue staff on the actual route, maintain barriers and devices, record near misses and verify corrective actions. Repeat observation after a phase change. This sustains the physical design; it is not a cheaper replacement.

Qualified Duties in Statute Law · ESEAP

Elimination
Change the route so the lorry drives through instead of reversing across the leisure-centre path, where geometry and delivery need permit. Keep public access within the design decision.
Substitution
Choose a compatible vehicle and delivery arrangement able to use a safer gate or manoeuvre; verify that the replacement actually reduces the harmful movement and does not introduce a new route, load or stability problem. A smaller vehicle alone does not remove crush energy.
Engineering controls
Install a robust barrier and protected accessible diversion between people and the vehicle zone. Fit suitable mirrors, cameras, lighting and alarms where needed; these physical visibility aids support the design and do not replace separation.
Administrative controls
Set delivery windows, agreed routing, driver and venue briefings and a trained marshal in a safe position where the assessment requires one. Supervise movement, manage device and barrier checks, investigate near misses and verify actions after phase changes.
PPE
Specify suitable high-visibility clothing for authorised workers near the controlled route, checking fit, condition and visibility. It cannot resist an impact or permit pedestrian access inside the vehicle exclusion zone.

What does a qualified statutory duty require?

The exact words of the applicable provision set the test. An absolute requirement must be met where it applies; “practicable” turns on what can be done; “so far as is reasonably practicable” asks whether the sacrifice of a further measure is grossly disproportionate to the risk it would reduce.

This page covers Great Britain (GB) and Northern Ireland (NI); first locate the site and provision. Start with the duty, its scope and any exceptions before classifying it. A sentence containing “must” is not automatically absolute: the object of that sentence may itself be qualified. Read the whole provision and any relevant regulations, definitions and approved code, then apply it to the activity and people at risk. This is a teaching framework, not a substitute for competent legal advice on a disputed provision. See GB Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974, section 2; NI Health and Safety at Work Order 1978, Article 4.

The operational chain is identify the duty → understand the risk → select and implement controls → test their effectiveness → review when conditions change. A duty holder should be able to explain which legal test applied and how the selected measure protects people. Neither a small budget nor an attractive commercial timetable removes a duty.

How do absolute, practicable and reasonably practicable differ?

Do not move a cost argument from one duty into another. The provision’s wording and context decide which test applies.

How to read the three teaching categories
Wording to checkWhat the decision asksWhat cannot settle it
Unqualified requirement (absolute where applicable)Has the specified requirement been met? Check the whole provision, scope and any express defence or exception.“It costs too much” or “we assessed the risk” does not replace a required act.
So far as practicableIs the measure technically feasible with current knowledge and capability in the circumstances? Verify the particular wording and relevant authority.Convenience, preference for a cheaper method or an unsupported claim of impossibility.
So far as is reasonably practicable (SFAIRP)What risk would the measure avert, and is the money, time or trouble of it grossly disproportionate to that benefit?A one-to-one cost–benefit calculation or an untested assertion that risk is “low”.

The GB Electricity at Work Regulations 1989 illustrate why the whole provision matters: regulations 4(1)–(3) expressly use the SFAIRP qualification. Regulation 4(4), on suitability, maintenance and proper use of protective equipment, does not contain that qualification; regulation 5 prohibits putting equipment into use where its strength or capability may be exceeded so as to cause danger, without that qualifier. Regulation 16 also sets a competence-or-supervision condition. The GB Work at Height Regulations 2005, Schedule 4 paragraph 5 uses “so far as practicable” for preventing a fall-arrest safeguard itself causing injury. These are provision-specific examples, not labels for an entire regulation or a live-work decision. Terms such as “suitable”, “sufficient” and “adequate” also qualify requirements, but are not automatic synonyms for SFAIRP. The Health and Safety Executive for Northern Ireland (HSENI) explains the Northern Ireland (NI) distinction between specific and qualified duties.

For the unqualified requirements in regulations 4(4), 5 and 16, also read regulation 29: in criminal proceedings it provides an express defence based on taking all reasonable steps and exercising all due diligence to avoid the offence. That defence does not rewrite the substantive duty as SFAIRP or give permission to ignore it. HSE HSR25, paragraphs 57–60, 77–80, 235 and 244.

Read the provision before choosing a test

Start: confirm jurisdiction, duty holder, activity, scope, exceptions and any express defence. Then follow the actual words:

  • Unqualified requirement → meet the specified requirement; check any express defence separately.
  • Practicable wording → test technical feasibility with current knowledge and capability in these circumstances.
  • SFAIRP wording → follow relevant good practice, identify further protection and compare its safety benefit with genuine money, time and trouble; the test is weighted towards safety.

All three routes → implement the selected lawful controls, verify them in the task and review when conditions change. A risk score or certificate does not choose the legal test.

What do ALARP and gross disproportion mean in practice?

The starting presumption favours a risk-reduction measure. To reject it under a reasonably practicable duty, the duty holder needs a reasoned case that the sacrifice is grossly disproportionate to the risk reduction.

SFAIRP is the wording commonly used in statutes and regulations. ALARP—“as low as reasonably practicable”—is the closely related risk-management expression. The comparison considers likelihood and severity of harm and the reduction a proposed measure can achieve, set against money, time and trouble. It is weighted toward safety. A serious possible outcome can justify substantial effort even when it is unlikely.

Use established relevant good practice first. If it already identifies a suitable control, an elaborate numerical calculation is rarely a sound reason to ignore it. Where a choice genuinely remains, state the assumptions and uncertainties, compare practicable options and ask what additional risk each would remove. Gross disproportion is not a fixed ratio or an equal-cost/equal-benefit test.

The concept does not promise zero risk and does not confer a general licence to trade lives for money. It also does not transfer the burden of controlling the hazard to workers by relying only on their care. Higher-consequence or uncertain hazards deserve more careful evidence and specialist input.

How should a manager make a defensible control decision?

Write down the duty, exposure and options before deciding whether any further measure is grossly disproportionate. Implement and verify controls; a risk score alone is not the decision.

At BuildOut, the starting point is the actual vehicle route and the exact duty that applies, not the team’s preferred control. The manager first asks whether the delivery can avoid reversing beside people, then whether the route can be physically separated. Only after comparing the real options and relevant good practice should a SFAIRP qualifier be used to assess any further measure. A practicable requirement has its own wording and test; neither label can be inferred from the hazard alone. See HSE: steps needed to manage risk.

The decision record should be short enough to use but complete enough to challenge: identify who could be struck, the credible severity, the option rejected, the reason and the interim protection. Record who checked the installed barrier and what would cause a fresh decision. If people remain exposed while that reasoning is unresolved, the operational answer is to hold the delivery.

A proportionate decision record
StepQuestion to answerEvidence
1. Locate the requirementWhich jurisdiction, provision, people and activity apply? What are the actual qualifying words?Text of the provision, competent interpretation and task scope.
2. Understand the exposureWho might be harmed, how severe could it be, and what makes exposure likely?Work observation, incidents, worker input, equipment condition and relevant guidance.
3. Identify controlsWhat can avoid or reduce the hazard at source? What does relevant good practice call for?Design or method options, manufacturer information, consultation and competent advice.
4. Decide and actWhich measures are required? If SFAIRP leaves a genuine choice, what risk does each further measure avert and what sacrifice would it require?Dated reasoning, named owner, funding, interim protection and deadline.
5. Verify and reviewDo installed measures work in the real task, including unusual conditions and contractors?Inspection, observation, test, action close-out and change triggers.

For significant risk, record the rejected options and why, not only the chosen control. Where an urgent deficiency creates exposure, restrict or stop the task while the decision is resolved. The number of employees affects some documentation requirements in GB—the HSE says significant findings must be recorded at five or more employees—but it does not mean a smaller employer can leave a serious risk uncontrolled.

A completed BuildOut decision: barrier before delivery

Hypothetical GB teaching record. BuildOut is the employer conducting the delivery undertaking and the leisure-centre visitors are people other than its employees. The relevant wording in HSWA section 3(1) is “so far as is reasonably practicable”. The site still checks other applicable duties; this example does not turn an unqualified requirement into a cost choice.

Exposure and further protection
A reversing lorry crosses an open visitor path. A collision could kill a visitor. A robust barrier and controlled, accessible diversion would remove the routine pedestrian crossing of the reversing zone during the delivery. That observed route separation is the protection claimed; no invented percentage reduction is used.
Real constraint and decision
The drive-through option cannot accommodate the actual vehicle swept path without entering the building access. Keep that drawing and reject that route in its present form. A suitable temporary barrier and diversion are feasible; assume a supplier quotation of £1,200 and half a day for installation, both invented for this example. A convenience delay and that quoted cost do not demonstrate gross disproportion against the credible fatal exposure. Install and verify the separation before delivery; hold the movement meanwhile.
Retained alternatives
Keep redesigning the entrance or choosing a compatible delivery vehicle under review. A smaller lorry still needs load/stability and swept-path checks. Do not replace separation with a marshal alone while an open public crossing remains. If the accessible diversion cannot be provided, retain the hold and develop another controlled route.
Owner and release evidence
The project manager funds the measure; the logistics lead and venue manager trial the route with no public present, inspect barrier continuity and confirm accessible access. Release only when observation demonstrates separation. A moved barrier, inaccessible route, visitor breach or changed vehicle triggers a stop and fresh decision. There is no universal monetary ratio in this judgement.

Before → after route check: open public path × reversing zone → barrier separates vehicle space from the accessible pedestrian diversion. Check the new entrance, crossing and emergency-access conflicts before using the diversion.

How can the hierarchy of controls guide reasonably practicable workplace risk reduction?

In the BuildOut example, the hazard is a moving vehicle. A person can enter its path or be trapped against a fixed object, causing immediate crush injury or death. The legal qualifier is assessed against this real harm mechanism, not against an abstract risk score.

ERICPD and HSE’s five-level hierarchy are related planning lenses, not identical statutory ladders: ERICPD reduction includes substitution, isolation maps to physical engineering where it separates people, and its discipline step is administrative assurance. The table tests every level against the actual task, including why a higher-order choice may not be feasible. HSE explains the five-level order and PPE as last resort

BuildOut is an illustrative vehicle route. HSE guidance supports the GB example; a Northern Ireland workplace must check its own HSENI route and exact applicable provision before transferring the control decision. Northern Ireland on-site traffic guidance

Reversing, blind spots, a changing public route, poor lighting, a missing barrier or a distracted driver can increase the chance of contact. The vehicle’s mass and constrained escape space affect the likely severity. HSE describes people being knocked down, run over or crushed; no long-latency disease mechanism is claimed for this collision example. A near miss, a person crossing the planned route or a failed barrier is a stop-and-review signal, not proof that a collision is unlikely. See HSE: separating pedestrians and vehicles; HSE: introduction to workplace transport safety.

BuildOut delivery harm pathway and stop signals
Task or exposureRoute and likely harmWarning or stop signal
Reversing beside a public routeVehicle enters a pedestrian path; impact or trapping can cause fractures, traumatic crush injury or death.Unexpected pedestrian, blocked sightline or route change: hold the movement and restore separation.
Loading and vehicle departureA person enters a changing loading zone; vehicle or load movement can strike or crush them.Unbriefed driver, open gate or damaged barrier: stop and reassess before loading or departure.

ERICPD is a control-planning framework, not statutory wording. It means Eliminate, Reduce or substitute, Isolate, Control, personal protective equipment (PPE) and Discipline. The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) hierarchy groups similar measures as elimination, substitution, engineering, administrative controls and PPE. In this scenario, “discipline” means reliable briefing, supervision and checks, not worker blame. A combination may be needed; later levels do not excuse a feasible source or separation control. On a narrow screen, scroll the following tables sideways to inspect every column.

A one-way route may move conflict to a different gate; a smaller vehicle may increase delivery frequency; a pedestrian diversion may create an inaccessible route; and a marshal can be exposed if placed in the vehicle path. Assess these new hazards before accepting the control. The applicable duty wording and relevant good practice still govern the legal decision.

Classification check: mirrors, cameras, lighting, alarms and barriers are physical engineering measures. Scheduling, routing instructions, marshal arrangements and verification are administrative measures. Maintain both; the management arrangements do not change the classification of the equipment.

How does the legal test change a live delivery decision?

BuildOut must find the applicable duties first, then control the vehicle–pedestrian risk and verify the arrangement at the leisure centre. It cannot use ALARP language to waive a separate absolute requirement.

BuildOut Ltd: reversing beside a leisure centre

Task, material and setting: BuildOut Ltd plans reversing deliveries beside an occupied leisure centre. Vehicle movements may intersect a public walking route. This is a SHARE teaching scenario, not evidence of BuildOut’s actual operation.

People and prerequisites: Drivers, bankspeople, centre staff and the public may be affected. The project and venue managers need the site location, applicable duty wording, a shared delivery plan and the actual pedestrian movements before authorisation.

Before: The project manager confirms the GB or NI location, applicable traffic and general-duty provisions, and the delivery route. Where the work can affect the public, they check GB section 3 or NI Article 5, as applicable. They inspect the real space with the centre manager and drivers, check pedestrian movements and consult workers. They do not begin by assigning a low numerical score.

During: Avoid reversing if the layout and delivery method allow it. Otherwise separate vehicles and pedestrians, use an agreed route and delivery window, provide suitable physical controls and trained supervision, and check the live movement. A high-visibility vest alone is a weak answer to an uncontrolled vehicle–pedestrian interface.

Hold or stop: If separation is missing, the public route changes, visibility falls or a marshal is absent, hold deliveries. The managers reassess and agree a safe method with the centre; a contractor cannot simply take the same route because it worked yesterday.

Completion and hand-back: Observe a complete delivery, confirm that temporary barriers and signs remain until the vehicle leaves, and restore the pedestrian route with the venue manager. Assign any defect and check closure before the next movement.

Evidence: Record the relevant duty wording, observed exposure, options, why controls were selected, owners and verification. If a further measure is rejected under SFAIRP, document its risk reduction and why its sacrifice is grossly disproportionate. Retain the observation and corrective actions.

If a specific applicable rule requires an action without SFAIRP wording, complete that action as well. If a proposed control is feasible but cannot be fitted to this exact layout, document the physical constraint and seek an alternative; “practicable” is not shorthand for the cheapest option. For a SFAIRP decision, use the actual risk reduction and sacrifice, with greater scrutiny where a vehicle could strike a person. The final legal classification of a specific provision needs competent review.

Where else does this qualified-duty reasoning apply?

The legal method transfers across sectors; the actual hazard, strongest feasible control and applicable provision must be checked afresh at each site.

A factory forklift crossing, a construction delivery, a hotel service entrance and a depot bay all expose people to moving vehicles, but they do not have the same geometry, work pattern or legal provision. The common sequence is to identify the contact path, remove an avoidable conflict, separate the routes where feasible and verify what remains. The table keeps the harm mechanism in view while showing which field condition should stop the activity. See HSE: introduction to workplace transport safety.

Vehicle-interface transfer examples, not site approvals
Sector and peopleHarm route and strongest controlResidual check or stop point
Manufacturing: forklift crossing a factory pedestrian route; operators and production staffA moving fork truck can strike or crush a person. Redesign flow to avoid the crossing, then isolate with separate routes and protected crossing.Check shift-change and maintenance movements; stop for a blocked or bypassed barrier. Factory traffic lead checks crossing design at shift change. Source: HSE: separating pedestrians and vehicles / HSENI: separating pedestrians and vehicles
Construction: delivery to an occupied site; workers, contractors and neighboursReversing plant or lorry can trap a person. Plan a drive-through or exclusion zone, with agreed gate control and supervision.Recheck after a phase change; hold when public access or visibility changes. Project manager checks gate and diversion after each phase change. Source: HSE: separating pedestrians and vehicles / HSENI: separating pedestrians and vehicles
Hospitality: service delivery beside hotel or restaurant guest access; staff and guestsA reversing service vehicle can strike a guest. Choose an off-route loading arrangement or physically separate guest and vehicle routes.Check events, queues and accessible diversion; suspend unloading if guests enter the controlled area. Venue manager checks guest route and accessible diversion before delivery. Source: HSE: separating pedestrians and vehicles / HSENI: separating pedestrians and vehicles
Logistics: HGV reversing at a depot bay; drivers, loaders and visiting contractorsA person between trailer and bay can be crushed. Design the yard and bay to keep pedestrians out and reduce reversing.Check gates, brakes, communication and unfamiliar drivers; stop for a person in the exclusion zone. Depot manager checks bay exclusion, unfamiliar drivers and vehicle condition. Source: HSE: separating pedestrians and vehicles / HSENI: separating pedestrians and vehicles

These are transfer examples of the same vehicle–pedestrian mechanism, not claims that every sector has an identical statutory duty or layout. A hotel’s guest route and a depot’s trailer bay call for different designs. Each manager must check local law, equipment, people and foreseeable changed conditions before applying the qualified-duty test.

Which arguments commonly fail?

An undocumented “low risk” label, a lack of funds or reliance on a worker to compensate for a missing control cannot establish reasonable practicability.

  • Misreading the law: classify a sentence from its first verb alone, or assume guidance has the same status as the statute.
  • False economy: choose a cheaper method before understanding who could be harmed and what established good practice requires.
  • Paper control: sign a risk assessment while the guard, separation, maintenance or supervision is absent in practice.
  • Wrong comparison: compare total project cost to total business benefit instead of the sacrifice of a further safety measure to the risk reduction it would deliver.
  • Untested normality: assess a routine day but overlook setup, cleaning, maintenance, breakdown, night work or contractors.
  • Post-event reconstruction: write down a balancing exercise only after an incident.

The practical response is to stop or restrict exposed work, recheck the provision and risk with competent people, implement interim protection and record a dated decision. Share the revised method with those who must apply it. A worker’s shortcut may be evidence that the chosen system is unusable, poorly supervised or inadequately resourced; investigate the system as well as the act.

What evidence makes a decision reviewable?

A reviewer should be able to trace the legal requirement and risk to the selected controls, observe them working and see how changes trigger a new decision.

Keep the relevant provision and interpretation, task-specific risk assessment, options and assumptions, worker or contractor consultation, competent advice, decision owner and date. Attach design drawings or equipment specifications when they explain feasibility. Keep records of installation, inspections, maintenance, briefings and actual observation. For rejected options, state the expected further risk reduction and the sacrifice, including uncertainty. Do not invent a numerical “gross disproportion factor” where none applies.

Assurance is more than the existence of a policy. Sample a shift and ask workers and supervisors to describe the same controls. Compare the answer with the condition of the plant, incident and near-miss reports, overdue actions and management review. HSG65 supports planning, implementation, checking and action. Review promptly when the process, equipment, people, evidence or law changes.

Who needs competence to apply a qualified duty?

General awareness helps staff spot failed controls; classification and risk-versus-sacrifice decisions need competent people who can explain the provision, the exposure and the evidence.

A classroom definition does not authorise someone to approve a live vehicle route. Assess competence by asking the person to work through the actual site decision, challenge an unsafe shortcut and show what would make them hold or revise it. Reassess after a legal change, new method, incident or observed misunderstanding; no universal course expiry is implied.

Qualified-duty competence by role
RoleLearning and demonstrationAssessor, record and reassessment trigger
General staff and people nearbyRecognise a failed barrier and report it; understand that a risk score does not authorise exposure.Supervisor checks understanding during induction; revisit after route or task change.
Drivers, operators and contractorsFollow the actual route and stop rules; demonstrate safe movement and communication.Competent supervisor observes the task and records scope; recheck after a changed vehicle or near miss.
Supervisors and coordinatorsFind the applicable method, challenge missing controls and decide when to hold and escalate.Manager reviews a live briefing and hold record; reassess after a failed control or legal uncertainty.
Managers, designers and purchasersUnderstand the duty qualifier, compare feasible controls and resource the chosen design.Competent adviser tests a real risk/sacrifice decision and installation evidence; revisit after design or law change.
Legal, safety and audit specialistsInterpret jurisdiction and source status, examine assumptions, sample control effectiveness and unresolved options.Professional lead reviews traceable advice and audit findings when new evidence or regulation appears.

What do the legal and control terms mean?

Keep the duty wording and the control method distinct when explaining a decision.

Qualified-duty acronyms and terms
TermFull form or descriptionMeaning in this decision
SFAIRPSo far as is reasonably practicableStatutory wording that calls for a safety-weighted risk-versus-sacrifice judgement.
ALARPAs low as reasonably practicableRelated risk-management expression for reducing risk through reasonably practicable measures.
ACOPApproved Code of PracticeA regulator-approved code with special legal status if a relevant prosecution follows.
PPEPersonal protective equipmentA lower-order safeguard for residual exposure, not a substitute for feasible route separation.
ERICPDEliminate, Reduce, Isolate, Control, PPE, DisciplineA practical control-planning framework, not the wording of a statutory duty.
HSEHealth and Safety ExecutiveThe GB workplace health and safety regulator.
HSENIHealth and Safety Executive for Northern IrelandThe NI workplace health and safety regulator.
GB and NIGreat Britain and Northern IrelandSeparate jurisdictions with different primary health and safety legislation.
ISOInternational Organization for StandardizationA standards body; ISO 45001 is voluntary and does not replace legislation.
Duty holderPerson or organisation to whom a duty appliesThe party responsible for meeting the applicable provision.
Gross disproportionSafety-weighted comparison of sacrifice with risk reductionThe further measure is normally taken unless its sacrifice is clearly excessive relative to the risk it would avert.