SHARE Knowledge Hub
HIRA: Hazard Identification and Risk Assessment
HIRA—hazard identification and risk assessment—connects a real task to a credible harm scenario, people affected, existing safeguards and a decision to improve control. A matrix can help compare priorities, but a low-frequency, high-consequence electrical or major-accident scenario still needs robust controls and competent judgement. Apply the legal instrument for the actual GB or NI site, involve people who do the work, and verify barriers before authorising the task.
Understanding HIRA: Hazard Identification and Risk Assessment
Hazard identification and risk assessment is the connected process of finding what could cause harm, understanding who or what could be affected and how, evaluating the risk in the actual circumstances, selecting further preventive and protective measures, implementing them, recording significant findings where required, and reviewing whether the controls remain effective. The abbreviation HIRA is widely used, but UK law normally speaks of risk assessment rather than prescribing a universal document called a HIRA.
Why this matters at work
Typical hazard: The assessment names a hazard but does not explain exposure route, energy transfer, dose, duration or escalation.; How harm occurs: Controls are chosen for the wrong mechanism or only the visible acute effect, leaving chronic and combined harm unmanaged.; Potential injury or illness: Cuts, fractures, burns, electric injury, hearing loss, HAVS, dermatitis, asthma, poisoning, infection, MSDs, stress-related illness, cancer or death.
Weak assessments copy a generic template, confuse hazard with outcome, list everyone without exposure detail, score before understanding the scenario, ignore health and non-routine work, treat training and PPE as default controls, or close actions without field verification.
How organisations manage this in practice
The assessment should identify what is already controlled, what further action is reasonably practicable, who owns it and when it must happen. It must not describe a proposed control as though it already protects people. Temporary or interim measures need limits, review and a route to permanent resolution. The appropriate control standard follows the applicable duty; in-scope GB COMAH prevention and limitation duties use all measures necessary.
Separate current controls from proposed actions. The residual risk statement should reflect controls that genuinely exist and work. If an action is required before work begins, say so explicitly. If work continues under interim measures, record their limits, authorisation, monitoring and expiry. High-risk decisions should be visible to people with authority and resources.
A current assessment reflects work as done. It considers normal and non-routine work, maintenance, cleaning, testing, start-up, shutdown, emergencies, foreseeable misuse, shared workplaces, contractor interfaces and change. It distinguishes confirmed evidence, reasonable inference, assumption and unresolved uncertainty. Unknowns with material consequences should trigger verification, specialist input or a hold point.
Action closure requires more than changing a status. Verify that the physical or organisational measure was implemented, related documents and training were updated, affected people were informed, and the control achieved the intended outcome without creating new risk. Complex or safety-critical actions may need independent or specialist review.
What are the key facts about HIRA?
The key facts are that HIRA identifies hazards, turns them into credible scenarios and then selects controls that can be verified.
What are the key facts about HIRA? — part 1 of 2
Read the complete visual as text
- The key facts are that HIRA identifies hazards, turns…: The key facts are that HIRA identifies hazards, turns them into credible scenarios and then selects controls that can be verified.
- Hazard comes first: You cannot assess risk properly until the hazard and exposure route are clear.
- Scenario matters: Risk depends on who is exposed, what task is done, how often and what could realistically go wrong.
What are the key facts about HIRA? — part 2 of 2
Read the complete visual as text
- Controls must match the hazard: Dust needs capture, moving machinery needs guarding, work at height needs fall prevention and major hazards need barriers.
- Risk registers should stay live: A register is useful only if owners, actions, controls and review dates are kept current.
- Review is part of HIRA: Change, incidents, weak signals and audit findings should update the assessment.
Hazard comes first
You cannot assess risk properly until the hazard and exposure route are clear.
Scenario matters
Risk depends on who is exposed, what task is done, how often and what could realistically go wrong.
Controls must match the hazard
Dust needs capture, moving machinery needs guarding, work at height needs fall prevention and major hazards need barriers.
Risk registers should stay live
A register is useful only if owners, actions, controls and review dates are kept current.
Review is part of HIRA
Change, incidents, weak signals and audit findings should update the assessment.
What does HIRA mean in plain English?
HIRA is the disciplined process of asking what could hurt people, how it could happen, how bad it could be and what will be done about it.
A weak HIRA lists hazards as single words: electricity, chemicals, vehicles, manual handling. A strong HIRA describes the scenario: an electrician isolates the wrong circuit during night maintenance; a forklift reverses into a pedestrian at a blind corner; solvent vapour builds up in a small room during cleaning; a flange is opened while trapped pressure remains. HSE managing risks and risk assessment
This is why HIRA is useful for all experience levels. Beginners learn the difference between hazard and risk. Supervisors learn what to check before work starts. Professionals learn how assessments link to registers, standards, barriers and assurance.
| Building block | Plain-English question | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Hazard | What has the potential to cause harm? | Moving conveyor. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Scenario | How could harm happen? | Worker clears blockage without isolation. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| People affected | Who could be harmed? | Operator, cleaner, maintenance contractor. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Existing controls | What already prevents or reduces harm? | Guard, interlock, isolation procedure and training. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Residual risk | What risk remains? | Unexpected restart if isolation is skipped. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Action | What needs to improve? | Add lock-off point, supervisor check and blockage tool. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
How should HIRA be completed step by step?
A good HIRA follows a clear sequence from scope through hazard identification, risk evaluation, control selection and review.
The step-by-step route below works for simple tasks and complex risk studies. The level of detail changes with risk. A low-risk office task may need a short assessment. A confined space, lifting operation, chemical process or construction excavation needs deeper planning, competent input and stronger evidence. HSE managing risks and risk assessment
The most common failure is starting with a template rather than the work. The team should observe the task, talk to workers, check history and understand the environment before scoring risk.
| Step | What to do | Output |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Define scope | State the task, process, area, lifecycle stage and people affected. | Clear assessment boundary. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| 2. Gather information | Review drawings, SDS, procedures, incident history, monitoring and worker feedback. | Evidence base. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| 3. Identify hazards | Find sources of harm, exposure routes and energy sources. | Hazard list. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| 4. Build scenarios | Describe credible ways harm could occur. | Risk scenarios. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| 5. Assess risk | Consider likelihood, severity, exposure, uncertainty and vulnerable groups. | Initial risk rating. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| 6. Select controls | Use ERICPD and legal prevention principles. | Control plan. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| 7. Assign actions | Set owners, due dates, resources and verification evidence. | Action tracker. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| 8. Record and brief | Record significant findings and brief affected people. | Risk assessment and briefing record. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| 9. Verify | Check controls at the point of work and through assurance. | Inspection, monitoring or audit evidence. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| 10. Review | Update after change, incident, learning or control failure. | Updated assessment and register. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
What types of hazards should HIRA consider?
HIRA should look beyond obvious safety hazards and include health, environment, process, human factors and organisational hazards.
When this HIRA lists “environment”, distinguish the work environment affecting worker safety from environmental releases or ecological impact. Those may need separate assessment and legal routes rather than being assumed covered by the occupational risk score. HSE managing risks and risk assessment HSE managing risks and risk assessment
A mature HIRA covers the full risk picture. For example, a cutting task might involve abrasive wheel burst, silica dust, noise, HAVS, fire, manual handling, electrical supply, public interface, waste and competence. Looking at only the immediate injury hazard misses health and system risks.
The right hazard categories depend on the work. Construction, process plants, healthcare, workshops, offices and leisure operations will have different emphasis.
| Hazard category | Examples | Control focus |
|---|---|---|
| Physical | Noise, vibration, heat, cold, radiation, pressure and stored energy. | Eliminate, isolate, engineer and monitor exposure. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Chemical | Dust, fume, vapour, mist, gas, liquid and contaminated surfaces. | COSHH assessment, substitution, LEV, hygiene and surveillance. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Biological | Blood, sewage, animal waste, bird droppings, mould, bacteria and viruses. | Avoidance, hygiene, cleaning, vaccination where relevant and PPE. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Safety | Vehicles, machinery, electricity, work at height and confined spaces. | Physical controls, permits, isolation and supervision. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Ergonomic | Manual handling, repetitive work, awkward posture and DSE. | Design, handling aids, task rotation and equipment fit. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Psychosocial | Workload, fatigue, lone working, violence, poor support and stressors. | Work design, staffing, support and management action. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Process safety | Loss of containment, ignition, overpressure, runaway reaction and toxic release. | Barrier management, MOC, operating limits and emergency response. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
How does a hazard become a risk scenario?
A hazard becomes useful in HIRA when it is described as a credible event with causes, consequences and exposed people.
Hazard-to-scenario examples — part 1 of 2
Read the complete visual as text
- Electricity: Weak wording: Electric shock. Better HIRA scenario: Maintenance worker contacts live conductor after isolation is not proved dead.
- Dust: Weak wording: Dust inhalation. Better HIRA scenario: Operative dry cuts blockwork in enclosed area and inhales respirable crystalline silica.
- Vehicle: Weak wording: Forklift accident. Better HIRA scenario: Forklift reverses from racking aisle and strikes pedestrian at blind crossing.
Hazard-to-scenario examples — part 2 of 2
Read the complete visual as text
- Pressure: Weak wording: Pressure release. Better HIRA scenario: Technician opens flange with trapped pressure after drain is blocked.
- Work at height: Weak wording: Fall from ladder. Better HIRA scenario: Worker overreaches from unsecured ladder during short-duration repair.
This is the learning step many people miss. The word 'chemical' is not a risk scenario. 'Cleaner uses a solvent in a small unventilated plant room for 40 minutes and becomes dizzy' is a scenario. That scenario allows the assessor to select controls that match the route of exposure. HSE electrical isolation case learning
Scenario thinking also helps exam answers. It demonstrates that the learner can apply knowledge rather than list generic hazards.
| Hazard | Weak wording | Better HIRA scenario |
|---|---|---|
| Electricity | Electric shock. | Maintenance worker contacts live conductor after isolation is not proved dead. HSE electrical isolation case learning |
| Dust | Dust inhalation. | Operative dry cuts blockwork in enclosed area and inhales respirable crystalline silica. HSE human factors in risk assessment |
| Vehicle | Forklift accident. | Forklift reverses from racking aisle and strikes pedestrian at blind crossing. HSE human factors in risk assessment |
| Pressure | Pressure release. | Technician opens flange with trapped pressure after drain is blocked. HSE human factors in risk assessment |
| Work at height | Fall from ladder. | Worker overreaches from unsecured ladder during short-duration repair. HSE human factors in risk assessment |
How should risk rating be used sensibly?
Risk rating should support judgement and prioritisation, not hide uncertainty behind a number.
Example: a wrong-circuit maintenance task may be judged unlikely on a 5×5 matrix, but contact with live conductors could be fatal. A low arithmetic score cannot replace secure isolation, proving dead, competence and a hold point when the circuit identity is uncertain. HSE risk guidance calls for suitable, proportionate assessment and actual control; the matrix is a local aid, not a legal approval threshold. HSE managing risks and risk assessment HSE electrical isolation case learning HSE managing risks and risk assessment
A five-by-five matrix can help rank actions, but it is not a substitute for competence. Two assessors may score the same risk differently if the scenario is vague, the controls are uncertain or exposure frequency is unknown. Good HIRA records the assumptions behind the score.
For high-consequence hazards, do not let a low likelihood score create complacency. Major accident hazards, fatal risks and irreversible health effects often require robust controls even when events are rare.
| Issue | Weak approach | Better approach |
|---|---|---|
| Vague scenario | Scores 'fire' as a hazard. | Scores a defined ignition and fuel release scenario. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Overconfidence | Assumes existing controls always work. | Checks evidence of inspection, testing and use. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Low likelihood, high consequence | Accepts low score without review. | Challenges safeguards and emergency controls. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Different scorers | No calibration between teams. | Use examples, guidance and review sessions. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Action priority | Everything becomes medium risk. | Rank by severity, exposure, uncertainty and control weakness. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
How can the hierarchy of controls guide control selection after hazard identification and risk assessment?
HIRA should use ERICPD to identify stronger controls before relying on instruction, supervision or PPE.
Verify controls: Diagnosing an electrical equipment fault
Read the complete visual as text
- Actual task: An electrical fault is assessed before access; use competent personnel, suitable information and a method that avoids exposed live work.
- Evidence to check: circuit identity, all supplies, safe isolation and suitable test equipment
- Stop or hold condition: uncertain circuit, unexpected voltage or an unapproved need for live access
- Release evidence and owner: competent electrical owner accepts completed tests and safe reinstatement
Verify controls: Separating people from forklifts
Read the complete visual as text
- Actual task: Deliveries cross a pedestrian route beside a loading bay; assess visiting drivers, picking tasks and peak movements.
- Evidence to check: route separation, crossing sightlines and representative truck movements
- Stop or hold condition: damaged barrier, pedestrian intrusion or an unplanned reversing manoeuvre
- Release evidence and owner: transport manager verifies routes with drivers and pedestrians
ERICPD is a planning mnemonic. The parallel five-level hierarchy puts substitution explicitly after elimination and treats isolation as an engineering measure where it physically separates people; verify each candidate control on the actual task. HSE five-level hierarchy HSE five-level hierarchy HSE five-level hierarchy
Controls should be specific enough to inspect. 'Use suitable PPE' is weak. 'Wear face-fit-tested FFP3 RPE for the dusty removal task after wet suppression and on-tool extraction have been checked' is stronger because it names the condition, control and evidence.
Where the HIRA identifies safety critical controls, those controls should be listed in the risk register and linked to maintenance, inspection, competence or permit systems.
How should HIRA link to risk registers?
Significant HIRA outputs should feed a live risk register so risk ownership, controls and review are visible.
The risk register is where HIRA becomes manageable across a business. It should capture the topic, location, scenario, people affected, initial risk, key controls, residual risk, owner, review date, actions and assurance route. HSG65 Managing for health and safety
For process safety topics, the register should connect to major accident hazard events, risks and controlling barriers. This allows leaders to see whether risk is controlled by prevention, detection, control, mitigation and emergency response layers.
| Field | What to record | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Scenario | Specific harm route. | Line breaking releases flammable liquid from trapped section. HSG65 Managing for health and safety |
| People affected | Workers, contractors, public or vulnerable groups. | Maintenance team and nearby operators. HSG65 Managing for health and safety |
| Key controls | Controls that materially reduce risk. | Isolation, drain/vent, gas test, permit and fire watch. HSG65 Managing for health and safety |
| Control owner | Person accountable for keeping control effective. | Maintenance supervisor. HSG65 Managing for health and safety |
| Assurance | How control effectiveness is checked. | Permit audit, isolation verification and incident review. HSG65 Managing for health and safety |
| Review trigger | Event that reopens the HIRA. | Change, incident, failed gas test or procedure deviation. HSG65 Managing for health and safety |
How should workers be involved in HIRA?
Workers should help identify real hazards, shortcuts, exposure points and controls that will or will not work.
HIRA is stronger when it uses work as done. Operators, maintenance workers, cleaners, drivers and contractors often know the awkward step, missing tool, hidden exposure or confusing handover that the written procedure misses. HSE human factors in risk assessment
Worker involvement should be structured. Use task walk-throughs, pre-job briefings, post-job reviews, safety representative input and near-miss learning.
| Route | What it adds | Output |
|---|---|---|
| Task walk-through | Shows actual sequence and hidden hazards. | Updated scenario and controls. HSE human factors in risk assessment |
| Pre-job briefing | Checks understanding before work starts. | Agreed controls and stop-work triggers. HSE human factors in risk assessment |
| Post-job review | Captures what changed during the job. | Learning and HIRA update. HSE human factors in risk assessment |
| Near-miss discussion | Identifies weak controls before loss. | Improvement action. HSE human factors in risk assessment |
| Contractor input | Captures specialist method and interface risks. | Bridging controls and supervision plan. HSE human factors in risk assessment |
How should HIRA cover major accident hazards?
For process safety, HIRA should start with major accident scenarios and then map controlling barriers.
Major accident HIRA should consider loss of containment, fire, explosion, toxic release, overpressure, runaway reaction, hazardous area ignition, confined atmosphere and environmental escalation. The assessment should not stop at a risk score. It should identify safety critical controls and evidence that those controls are reliable. HSE COMAH process-safety assessment guidance
The major accident hazard register should show prevention, detection, control, mitigation, emergency response and assurance for each credible scenario.
| Scenario | Barrier type | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Tank overfill | High-level alarm, independent high-high trip and operator response. | Proof test, alarm response drill and shift log. HSE COMAH process-safety assessment guidance |
| Vapour cloud ignition | Hazardous area equipment, gas detection and ignition control. | DSEAR assessment, inspection and detector calibration. HSE COMAH process-safety assessment guidance |
| Pressure relief failure | Relief valve, written scheme and maintenance. | Applicable system-specific written scheme, competent-person examination report, due date and closure of safety-critical defects, with relief-device testing/maintenance evidence as appropriate. HSE COMAH process-safety assessment guidance |
| Toxic release | Containment, detection, isolation and emergency response. | Inspection, detector test and emergency drill record. HSE COMAH process-safety assessment guidance |
| Line break during maintenance | Isolation, drain, vent, permit and gas test. | Permit pack and field verification. HSE COMAH process-safety assessment guidance |
What evidence shows HIRA is working?
Good evidence shows that hazards were identified, controls were implemented and assurance is improving the system.
Evidence should follow the risk. A high-risk chemical task may need SDS, COSHH assessment, LEV record, exposure monitoring and health surveillance. A machinery task may need PUWER assessment, guarding inspection, isolation procedure and competence records. A process safety HIRA may need barrier test records, MOC and operating limit evidence. HSE managing risks and risk assessment
The point is not to collect documents for their own sake. It is to show that the assessment has changed the way work is planned, controlled and reviewed.
| Evidence | What it shows | Review point |
|---|---|---|
| Task observation | Assessment reflects work as done. | Repeat when method changes. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Risk register entry | Significant risk has owner and review date. | Review overdue actions. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Control verification | Controls exist and are used. | Check failures and trends. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Training record | People understand hazards and controls. | Refresh after change or incident. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Monitoring data | Exposure or performance is measured. | Act on high or uncertain results. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Audit finding | System weakness is identified. | Track corrective action to verified close-out. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
Which duties apply in Great Britain and Northern Ireland?
Apply the separate GB or NI instrument for the site and only where the task or threshold brings it into scope. The method taught on this page is not itself a legal duty.
The current site assessment must decide applicability. HRO principles, ERICPD and HIRA forms help implementation but do not confer compliance; a safety-critical task or major-accident scenario needs a demonstrated physical barrier. Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999 Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations (NI) 2000
| Decision | Great Britain | Northern Ireland | Applicability check |
|---|---|---|---|
| General hazard assessment and arrangements | Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974; Management Regulations 1999 Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999 | Health and Safety at Work (NI) Order 1978; Management Regulations (NI) 2000 Health and Safety at Work (NI) Order 1978 Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations (NI) 2000 | Confirm site, activity and threshold; verify current text. |
| Electrical maintenance in the worked example | Electricity at Work Regulations 1989 Electricity at Work Regulations 1989 | Electricity at Work Regulations (NI) 1991 Electricity at Work Regulations (NI) 1991 | Confirm site, activity and threshold; verify current text. |
| Hazardous substances where present | COSHH Regulations 2002 Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations 2002 | COSHH Regulations (NI) 2003 Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations (NI) 2003 | Confirm site, activity and threshold; verify current text. |
| Flammable substances where present | DSEAR 2002 Dangerous Substances and Explosive Atmospheres Regulations 2002 | DSEAR (NI) 2003 Dangerous Substances and Explosive Atmospheres Regulations (NI) 2003 | Confirm site, activity and threshold; verify current text. |
| Major-accident establishment if threshold tests are met | COMAH Regulations 2015 Control of Major Accident Hazards Regulations 2015 | COMAH Regulations (NI) 2015 Control of Major Accident Hazards Regulations (NI) 2015 | Confirm site, activity and threshold; verify current text. |
How should the selected controls be checked in practice?
ERICPD is used here as a planning mnemonic. The linked HSE five-level hierarchy is the official source for the order and relative reliability of controls; the two labels are not identical.
ERICPD and the five-level hierarchy are planning aids. Eliminate or substitute where possible; engineer barriers before relying on rules or PPE.
The five-level order is elimination, substitution, engineering, administrative controls and PPE. ERICPD adds useful prompts, but Isolate maps mainly to engineering and Discipline sustains controls; neither creates a new statutory rung. The proposed task measures are candidates for competent assessment, not universal requirements. HSE five-level hierarchy HSE five-level hierarchy
How should management verify controls for this task?
For maintenance of a potentially energised electrical circuit, the management check should start with a real control decision: Confirm whether the electrical task can be designed out or performed dead; verify circuit identity, isolation and prevention of re-energisation through the authorised competent person. Uncertainty keeps the work on hold. Name the person who will test it, keep evidence from the actual work, and reopen the assessment when the failure condition in the hierarchy table occurs. HSE management-system guidance.
A review should compare the planned control with what workers and supervisors can use in practice. Record the defect, owner, interim protection, verification and next review trigger so that a policy statement or certificate does not stand in for a working control.
How does HIRA support NEBOSH and process safety study?
HIRA supports study by turning abstract hazard words into practical risk scenarios, controls and evidence.
A strong learner answer explains the difference between hazard and risk, identifies who may be harmed, describes credible scenarios, applies hierarchy controls and explains how the assessment is recorded and reviewed. HSE managing risks and risk assessment
For process safety, good answers should refer to major accident hazard events, risks and controlling barriers such as containment, detection, isolation, relief, shutdown, mitigation and emergency response.
| Question | Good answer | Weak answer |
|---|---|---|
| Identify hazards | Includes task, people, environment, energy and exposure routes. | Lists generic words. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Assess risk | Uses scenario, likelihood, severity, uncertainty and control reliability. | Scores without explaining scenario. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Select controls | Uses ERICPD and specific examples. | Says training and PPE only. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Review | Triggers review after change, incident or control failure. | Says review annually only. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
What must each role demonstrate?
Observed task decisions and stop points establish useful evidence of competence; a briefing alone does not authorise safety-critical work.
Record who assessed the demonstration, what field task or simulation was observed, and what change triggers reassessment. Match specialist sign-off to the actual hazard. HSE training and competence
| Role | Demonstration | Assessor and record | Reassess when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Worker | Describe credible wrong-circuit scenario and stop work if isolation unknown. | Supervisor observes task walk-through. | Circuit or method changes. HSE electrical isolation case learning |
| Supervisor | Check people, barriers, uncertainty and authorisation before work. | Manager witnesses field check. | New hazard or failed check. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Electrical lead | Prove dead and secure isolation using competent method. | Qualified peer observes and records test. | System alteration or equipment fault. HSE electrical isolation case learning |
| Assessor | Challenge low-likelihood/high-consequence matrix result. | Competent peer reviews scenario and controls. | Near miss or new evidence. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Manager | Fund stronger controls and close register actions. | Senior leader samples field verification. | Barrier drift or overdue action. HSG65 Managing for health and safety |
What warning signs show HIRA is weak?
Weak HIRA usually shows up as generic wording, poor worker involvement and controls that cannot be verified.
A risk assessment may look complete because all boxes are filled in, but still fail as a control document. Warning signs include copied hazards, missing scenarios, no residual risk logic, no action owners, no review after change and supervisors who cannot explain the controls. HSE managing risks and risk assessment
Where work is high-risk, weak HIRA should stop progression until the assessment is made suitable and sufficient.
| Warning sign | Why it matters | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Hazards listed as single words | The assessment cannot identify the harm route. | Rewrite as credible scenarios. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| No worker input | Work as done may be missed. | Walk the task and involve workers. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Every control is PPE or training | Higher-order controls may be missed. | Apply ERICPD again. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| No risk register link | Significant risk may not be owned. | Add owner, review and assurance fields. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| No review after change | Controls may no longer match work. | Trigger MOC or reassessment. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
| Actions closed without evidence | Risk may remain uncontrolled. | Verify close-out at the point of work. HSE managing risks and risk assessment |
What do the acronyms and key terms mean?
Acronyms should be understood before they are used in assessments, briefings, audits or learning answers.
Acronyms can exclude newer readers if they are not explained. This section keeps the main terms available at the end of the page so the article stays readable while still supporting learners and audit users.
| Acronym | Meaning | Plain-English use |
|---|---|---|
| ALARP | As low as reasonably practicable | Risk reduction principle used to decide if further controls are needed. |
| COMAH | Control of Major Accident Hazards | Major hazard regulations for qualifying establishments. |
| COSHH | Control of Substances Hazardous to Health | Framework for hazardous substance exposure assessment and control. |
| DSEAR | Dangerous Substances and Explosive Atmospheres Regulations | Framework for fire and explosion risk from dangerous substances. |
| ERICPD | Eliminate, Reduce, Isolate, Control, PPE, Discipline | Practical hierarchy used when selecting controls. |
| HIRA | Hazard Identification and Risk Assessment | Structured hazard identification and risk assessment process. |
| MOC | Management of change | Formal review of risk before changes are made. |
| RAMS | Risk assessment and method statement | Planning document describing risks and methods. |

Unlock another resource
You have used this month’s two free downloads. Publish a post in your own words to unlock one more resource, or choose SHARE Individual for 10 downloads per month.
You decide whether to share. If you do, use the relevant platform disclosure tools and do not make claims you do not genuinely hold.